[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Friday, 23 March 2007, 14:43 GMT
Judge denies inmate's voting bid
A prisoner
Lord Clarke gave his ruling at the Court of Session
A judge has refused to free a prisoner who wanted to register to vote in the Scottish Parliament elections.

However Donald Birrell - who complained that his human rights had been breached - may still be able to win damages.

Birrell was let out on licence in May last year but is now back in jail after the licence was revoked last month.

Judge Lord Clarke gave his verdict at the Court of Session in Edinburgh on Friday and said the case had raised interesting and novel questions of law.

Birrell sought a judical review when his attempt to register to vote was refused because he had been imprisoned again.

He was one of three Scottish prisoners bringing legal action ahead of May's parliamentary and local government elections.

Under current laws - the 1983 Representation of the People Act - a ban on voting is imposed on all prisoners being held under a sentence.

Remand prisoners and those freed on licence are allowed to cast their vote.

I am entitled to balance the safety and protection of the public against the right of Birrell to take part in the election
Lord Clarke

The judge said he had "no hesitation" in deciding that Birrell, formerly from Glasgow, should remain in prison.

Rejecting Birrell's bid for freedom, Lord Clarke said: "I am entitled to balance the safety and protection of the public against the right of Birrell to take part in the election."

Scottish ministers, legally responsible for the decision to send Birrell back to prison, contested his action.

Their senior counsel, Paul Cullen QC, said Birrell's rights under the European Convention on Human Rights had not been breached.

Birrell's problem was the result of his own behaviour, said Mr Cullen. Birrell had also lodged a claim for 1,000 damages if he was not allowed to vote.

SNP justice spokesman Kenny MacAskill welcomed the judge's decision.

Spurious cases

"Clearly common sense has prevailed as people who breach the law forfeit some rights and must face the consequences of their actions," he said.

"Hard pressed courts and limited court time should be for serious offenders and important issues, not spurious cases such as this."

Separate cases are being brought by the other two inmates, Derek Traynor and James Fisher.

They hope to halt the elections altogether if they are successful.

The pair are seeking a court order to ban ministers from "carrying out any act to facilitate or promote the holding of the general election for membership of the Scottish Parliament".

The moves follow a ruling in January by Court of Session judges that a blanket ban on prisoners voting was not compliant with the European Convention on Human Rights.

Prisoner demands 'right to vote'
22 Mar 07 |  Scotland
Anger at convict's legal aid bill
08 Feb 07 |  Scotland
Holyrood row over May's election
25 Jan 07 |  Scotland
Court rules on prison voting ban
24 Jan 07 |  Scotland
Calls to give vote to prisoners
04 Apr 05 |  UK Politics


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific