BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 30 November 2006, 21:54 GMT
Scotland's history chart revealed
Presenter Neil Oliver
Presenter Neil Oliver revealed Scotland's essential history top 10
The Wars of Independence with Wallace and Bruce have topped a public poll to find the top 10 of Scottish history.

People living in Scotland were asked to cast their vote as part of a BBC Two television programme.

The bloody battles of Stirling Bridge and Bannockburn and the heroic figures of William Wallace and Robert the Bruce came out top with the public.

Academics, however, rated Scotland's involvement in World War One and the Treaty of the Union as more important.

How the public voted
The Wars of Independence
The Declaration of Arbroath
Medicine
James Clerk Maxwell
Robert Burns
The Reformation
James Watt
The Enlightenment
Covenanters
The Clearances

Hundreds of people took part in the BBC's poll to find out what were rated as the key moments in Scotland's history.

A total of 30 topics were whittled down from more than 1,000 nominations received from the public.

These were then debated by a panel of history professionals, including chair Professor Tom Devine, and a final 10 were decided upon.

The results were shown in the BBC television series Scotland's History: The Top 10 on Thursday evening - an hour-long special broadcast on St Andrew's Day.

Among the events suggested by the public but rejected by the experts were the Declaration of Arbroath, Irish immigration, drink and the Clearances.

How the experts voted
World War One
Unification
Reformation
The Scottish Empire
The Scottish City
Enlightenment
The Wars of Independence
Medicine
Treaty of Union
Covenanters

Other discarded suggestions included the historical figures of physicist James Clerk Maxwell, inventor James Watt and Robert Burns.

The show came at the end of a day which saw dozens of events held across the country to mark Scotland's patron saint.

Presenter Neil Oliver told BBC Scotland's news website: "It is perhaps no surprise that the public and the panel have differed but there is a marked gulf between the two."

He added: "Most notably Scottish achievement ranks much higher with the public than with the historians."




SEE ALSO
Scotland to pick historic top 10
10 Nov 06 |  Scotland
Union anniversary to be marked
09 Nov 06 |  Scotland

RELATED BBC LINKS

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Israeli professor gives lessons on the move
Reasons why the Copenhagen summit failed
Have protest fasts become a form of political blackmail?

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific