[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Monday, 1 August 2005, 19:19 GMT 20:19 UK
Spoof e-mail under fire from RSPB
Countryside Alliance leaflet
The e-mail encourages people to kill birds of prey
The chief executive of the Scottish Countryside Alliance has been condemned for forwarding an e-mail which urges people to shoot birds of prey.

Tony Andrews sent out a spoof e-mail in the guise of an RSPB leaflet, urging the recipients to kill sparrowhawks, which are a protected species.

He said he received the email from Songbird Survival, but the group has denied any knowledge of it.

The RSPB accused the SCA of condoning a "serious criminal act".

The e-mail shows a picture of a robin and suggests that to help protect garden birds, sparrowhawks should be shot.

Former alliance member Tom Chalmers, 47, from Paisley, was among those who received it.

Mr Chalmers, who runs a pro-hunting website, said: "I was horrified when I saw it. It was totally out of order and inappropriate, especially as they were using the RSPB logo and putting it across like it was an official document.

I am surprised you cannot see the amusing side of the e-mail
Tony Andrews
Scottish Countryside Alliance

"I was also deeply offended. It's just not funny when someone condones committing a criminal offence, especially as birds of prey are being persecuted in Scotland.

"I go shooting myself, but I am also a conservationist. I'm a supporter of the RSPB and believe the SCA should be working in co-operation with them."

After contacting the SCA to complain about the e-mail, Mr Chalmers received a response from Mr Andrews.

'Amusing side'

The e-mail said: "I am surprised you cannot see the amusing side of the e-mail which I sent you, as I did to other people.

"Clearly, if you take offence at such a light-hearted approach to RSPB single species protection policies, you cannot also support the concept of balance in wildlife management, which every country sports organisation in Scotland regards as key to good rural management."

Mr Andrews added that the control of raptors, including sparrowhawks, was the only way forward to have species diversity in Scotland.

Sparrowhawk (Picture taken by Mark Holloway)
Sparrowhawks are being accused of killing traditional songbirds

Andy Myles, spokesman for RSPB Scotland, said: "The Scottish Countryside Alliance have always publicly protested that they are opposed to wildlife crime.

"Passing this sad attempt at humour around the internet has all the appearances of condoning a serious criminal act and has a strong whiff of hypocrisy.

"Birds of prey face terrible threats from persecution and the Scottish Parliament have just recently tightened all of the law in this area."

He added that everyone in Scotland should have the right to see sparrowhawks and other birds of prey as an important part of wildlife.

"There has been a vast amount of coverage of wildlife crime in recent years and the public have been horrified that their wildlife is being slaughtered by self-appointed guarantors of balance in the countryside," he said.

Species 'decimated'

Mr Andrews told the BBC Scotland news website he received the e-mail from a contact at Songbird Survival.

"It was a spoof e-mail," he said. "I would never have created such an e-mail myself but thought it was amusing so I sent it out to a number of contacts.

"There are a number of examples in Scotland where traditional birds like skylarks, curlews and lapwings are being decimated by raptors that are out of control.

"The RSPB needs to get off its high horse and pay attention to the concerns of real people who don't often see raptors unless they are killing their beloved songbirds.

"The issue is about what kind of countryside we want."

But Michael Hope, a trustee of Songbird Survival, said the e-mail was not sent out by his group. He had not seen it until he contacted Mr Andrews to ask to see a copy of it, he added.

Pigeon report 'clears' raptors
24 Apr 04 |  Scotland
New powers cut bird poison cases
12 Apr 05 |  Scotland
Poison used to kill birds of prey
01 Apr 05 |  Scotland
Gamekeeper fined for laying traps
28 Jan 05 |  Scotland

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific