[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Tuesday, 7 June, 2005, 13:01 GMT 14:01 UK
'Standards' MSP resigns over gift
Labour MSP Ken Macintosh - image courtesy of Scottish Parliament website
Ken Macintosh received hospitality following a charity football match
The deputy convener of a Holyrood committee which rules on the MSPs' code of conduct has resigned from the post after failing to declare a gift.

Ken Macintosh did not register the 330 cost of hospitality he received at a charity football match and overnight accommodation courtesy of McDonald's.

The Labour MSP for Eastwood breached rules stating MSPs must declare gifts worth more than 250 within 30 days.

He said it was "a late declaration, a simple mistake, no more, no less".

Standards committee convener Brian Adam confirmed Mr Macintosh's resignation.

The committee concludes that there was no wilful intention to deceive the public or parliament on the part of Mr Macintosh
Brian Adam
Standards Committee convener

The MSPs' Code of Conduct requires them to register any foreign trips not paid for by the member, "whatever their purpose or nature".

Mr Macintosh had attended an inter-parliamentary football match in Cardiff in August last year.

He declared the gift in January as one costing more than 250, and gave its exact cost in March, but this breached the 30-day rule.

Cardiff trip

Mr Adam said the committee accepted that Mr Macintosh had "every intention" of publishing the information when he received it, as he had done following a similar visit to Cardiff in 2003.

"The committee concludes that there was no wilful intention to deceive the public or parliament on the part of Mr Macintosh," he added.

"However, setting aside Mr Macintosh's intention, his actions do constitute a breach of the Members' Interests Order.

"The code of conduct for MSPs makes it clear that responsibility in relation to registration of interests lies with each individual member and that a breach of the order is not a matter to be considered lightly."

The committee decided not to impose further sanctions on Mr Macintosh given the "public embarrassment" he has suffered and "the anticipated further public comment" arising from the complaint and publication of the report.

McConnell case

The decision to step down came on the same day First Minister Jack McConnell was cleared of breaking Scottish Parliament rules over his holiday at Kirsty Wark's Majorcan home.

The standards commissioner investigated five complaints against Mr McConnell, who failed publicly to declare the trips in his MSP register of interests.

Dr Jim Dyer ruled the accommodation did not amount to a benefit in kind and need not be registered.

Mr McConnell said he did nothing wrong over his trip at Hogmanay in 2004.

McConnell cleared in villa report
07 Jun 05 |  Scotland
Standards convener cleared
07 Oct 03 |  Scotland
Anger over MSP standards probe
25 Jun 03 |  Scotland

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific