[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Friday, 19 September, 2003, 09:46 GMT 10:46 UK
MSPs turn backs on Swinney
John Swinney
Mr Swinney has been criticised over a key policy
Two Nationalist MSPs have declared that they will not support John Swinney in a leadership ballot because of his position on independence.

Bruce McFee and Adam Ingram accused the SNP leader of watering down the party's commitment to independence during this year's Holyrood elections.

Mr McFee said he would abstain from the leadership vote at the party's conference in Inverness next week.

Mr Ingram said he planned to vote for Dr Bill Wilson, Mr Swinney's challenger.

This isn't a surprise - it's the same vote as it was when the contest was last fought three years ago
Fiona Hyslop
The Nationalist MSPs said Mr Swinney's position on independence had confused the voters and had led to a disappointing result for the party in May.

In the 2001 General Election and in this year's Holyrood campaign, Mr Swinney said the party would promise a referendum on independence after an SNP election victory.

This was a shift from the previous policy whereby winning an election would be considered a sufficient mandate.

Mr McFee, a list MSP for the West of Scotland, said: " I really can no longer endorse the direction that the leadership is taking.

Adam Ingram
Adam Ingram will vote against the leader
"Under John Swinney's leadership we're now told that the referendum would be in year two or year three of the SNP forming a government in Edinburgh."

"What is very clear is that this policy has been used by the leadership as a way of watering down the independence message, to say to people 'you can vote SNP without believing a word we say about independence'."

South of Scotland list MSP Mr Ingram told Scottish Television: "We spent far too much time at Scottish parliamentary elections telling people that voting SNP was not a vote for independence in terms of having a referendum."

The MSP said the strategy had been to "park" independence until a referendum, which "totally confused our supporters in particular, and we lost a lot of our core voters".


Mr McFee said the leadership had not taken into account fears that efforts would be made by the British Government to "destabilise" an SNP administration prior to the referendum.

He said: "Let's be quite clear about this. The leadership have used this policy for a reason that the party never intended and that was to make it an independence-like policy so that they could back-pedal the independence policy and as a Nationalist I fundamentally disagree with doing that.

Swinney loyalist Fiona Hyslop was unperturbed by reports that about a third of the party would not support Mr Swinney.

The Lothians MSP said the result might reflect the ballot in 2000 when Mr Swinney beat Alex Neil in the leadership contest.

She said: "This isn't a surprise - it's the same vote as it was when the contest was last fought three years ago."

Leadership challenger slams Swinney
14 Aug 03  |  Scotland
Swinney will defend leadership
25 Jul 03  |  Scotland
Swinney ties the knot
26 Jul 03  |  Scotland
Swinney reshuffles SNP pack
30 May 03  |  Scotland
Independence rethink denied
04 May 03  |  Scotland
SNP lose out at the polls
02 May 03  |  Scotland

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific