BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in:  UK: Scotland
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Friday, 19 April, 2002, 20:32 GMT 21:32 UK
Finnie suffers GM crop defeat
GM crops
Activists called for a moratorium on trials
Rural Development Minister Ross Finnie has suffered a defeat at the Scottish Liberal Democrat conference in Perth over the issue of GM crop trials.

Representatives voted by two to one against the continuation of the trials.

They also urged Mr Finnie to make the party's policy of caution on genetically-modified technology clear.

Ross Finnie
Ross Finnie said the trials should continue
The minister told the conference he had to accept European laws on the issue and allow the trials to continue.

After the vote Mr Finnie said he respected the view he had heard from his party colleagues.

But he added: "No-one has actually explained what we do in relation to the law."

The controversy came during a debate on food policy, in which several activists called for a moratorium on GM crop trials.

Activist Judy Hayman told the conference that research into GM crops should be driven by the needs of society, not the need for profit.

'Long-term damage'

"There is no evidence that the Scottish public wants GM," she said.

"We are not being Luddite, but we cannot risk long-term environmental damage which may be irreversible.

"The trouble is we don't know - and by the time we find out, it may be too late to prevent further damage."

Delegate Liz Dick said: "We say we need scientific evidence, and the trials themselves are not genuine scientific evidence.

Robin Harper
Robin Harper welcomed the vote
"The trials may be doing harm to organic farms."

Mr Finnie argued against the call for a halt to tests on legal grounds.

"We cannot be choosy about which European laws we accept and which we don't," he said.

However, despite his pleas delegates supported an amendment calling for an immediate moratorium on field testing and commercial growing of GM crops in Scotland.

It also said that GM testing should be restricted to enclosed laboratories.

The decision was welcomed by the Scottish Green Party.

'Slap in the face'

MSP Robin Harper said: "This vote shows that even one person working with people in other parties can have a profound effect on Scottish politics.

"I am elated that, contrary to the stance taken by some Liberal Democrat MSPs, the majority of the party has had the common sense to back the calls of Scottish Greens and vote to put a stop to the experimentation with the Scottish countryside that these GM trials represent."

The Scottish National Party's deputy environment spokeswoman Fiona McLeod said the decision was "a slap in the face" for Mr Finnie.

"It appears that, apart from the GM companies, the only person in Scotland who now supports the growing of GM crops is Ross Finnie.

"He is out on a limb and out of touch with the people of Scotland," she said.

See also:

17 Apr 02 | Scotland
MSPs want GM trial halted
28 Mar 02 | Scotland
Freedom for jailed GM crop protester
12 Mar 02 | Scotland
GM trials up for question
10 Sep 01 | Scotland
Finnie welcomes GM crops report
24 Aug 01 | Scotland
GM protesters in court
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Scotland stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Scotland stories