BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: UK: Scotland
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Monday, 21 January, 2002, 20:07 GMT
Inquiry told of 'crashing' stone
Fire engine holding ladder to third floor of building
Fire crews try to stop more stones from falling
Witnesses have relived the moments when stonework fell from the third floor of a building in Edinburgh, killing a waitress working in a café below.

Christine Foster, 26, an Australian who had just begun a working holiday, died after being hit by the masonry.

Five other people, tourists from Canada and the Netherlands, were injured in the incident at Ryan's Bar just off Princes Street in June 2000.

Giving evidence at a fatal accident inquiry, Susan Broussine, 51, a lecturer, said: "I heard what I thought was an explosion then there was lots of things smashing, lots of screaming.

Christine Foster
Christine Foster: Working holiday
"As I moved away I looked over my shoulder and there was a lady lying on the ground."

Ms Broussine suffered serious bruising after she was struck on the leg by the stonework.

Her friend, fellow lecturer Karen Lawson, was left bleeding after debris struck her on the head.

Another witness, Kenneth Owenson, told the inquiry at Edinburgh Sheriff Court: "Everyone was sitting outside enjoying themselves. It looked a nice place to meet.

'Spinning lead'

"Then suddenly the stones were coming down and one struck a lady in the head and people were falling all over the place.

"I saw lead spinning as it fell down. There was debris over about a five metre radius.

"An old lady was cut on the head and a man was lying on the ground."

Coping stone
One of the coping stones on the ground
The general manager of Ryan's Bar, Hamish Mair, said: "There was a huge noise of masonry crashing down. When the dust settled I ran outside and there was glass and chairs everywhere.

"Christine was lying on the floor."

News vendor Thomas Munroe, 61, told the inquiry that in six years of working opposite the bar at the junction of Princes Street and Hope Street he had never seen or heard of debris falling there.

Ms Foster, from Kalgoolie in Western Australia, was serving drinks when the accident happened.

She was a civil engineer by profession and lived in a shared flat in Edinburgh.

Her father Michael is attending the inquiry, which is expected to last two weeks.

The main issues to be examined are expected to include the specific cause to how traffic, pollution and other factors can generally affect older properties.

Morag Kinniburgh reports
"Customers told the court that they had heard rumbling noises"
See also:

29 Jun 00 | Scotland
Waitress killed by falling masonry
03 Apr 00 | UK
Rescuers return to building
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Scotland stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Scotland stories