BBC News: Election 2010 BBC News

Page last updated at 14:19 GMT, Thursday, 15 April 2010 15:19 UK

Political ad breakdown: Say Goodbye to Broken Promises

Nick Clegg

Brian Wheeler's review of election broadcasts

It's a good job the Liberal Democrats have not promised to tackle Britain's litter problem.

Nick Clegg is practically drowning in the stuff in the party's first general election broadcast.

The Lib Dem leader wanders along the banks of the Thames, leaving a vast trail of waste paper flapping about in his wake.

Title: Say Goodbye to Broken Promises
Starring: Nick Clegg, sheets of paper, not Vince Cable
Key scenes: Riverside pathway with papers blowing around, housing estate with papers blowing around, residential street with... you guessed it

The litter represents a "trail of broken promises" by Labour and the Conservatives over the past 30 years (the Lib Dems know all about playing the long game).

The broken promises Mr Clegg highlights - fairer taxes, better schools for everyone, cleaning up politics - would all be hotly disputed by Labour and the Tories and also happen to be the key themes of the Liberal Democrat manifesto.

But no matter, Mr Clegg cuts a reasonably convincing figure in his overcoat as he walks and talks through various suburban and rural scenes.

He talks directly into the camera in the same way the actor standing in for Gordon Brown in Labour's election broadcast did the other night.

The haunting soundtrack comes courtesy of Brian Eno, who somewhat bizarrely given his age (61), is Mr Clegg's official youth adviser.

Solo appearance

It's probably a shrewd move for Mr Clegg to focus on trust. This is what the polls say is in danger of strangling this election campaign at birth. No one, it seems, believes a word anybody is saying.

Then again the Lib Dems' opponents will point out that Mr Clegg has never had a chance to break any promises as his party has never been in government at Westminster.

Papers strewn
Paper... lots and lots of it

His other major theme is fairness - a direct raid on Labour territory. Most of the broken promises highlighted also seem to be Labour ones, such as free university tuition, a totemic Lib Dem policy which Mr Clegg seemed keen to ditch at one stage before his party dug its heels in.

At least Mr Clegg has managed to shake off Vince Cable for this broadcast. The two have been joined at the hip for the past week.

The Lib Dem Treasury spokesman is seen as the party's best electoral asset - he seems to be one of the few politicians people are willing to listen to at the moment.

Mr Clegg is always quick to stress that he does not mind sharing the spotlight with the sage of the credit crunch, but it must be gratifying to stand on his own merits for a change.

Perhaps they made Vince clear up the litter afterwards.

Below is a selection of your comments.

Anyone else think this spookily reminds them of 28 Days Later? All that paper blowing around, the strange and ominous music, the largely empty streets... Is Clegg daring to tell us what other parties won't - we're in fact ruled by zombies?
Slightly Scared, UK

An interesting advert and it was clear that many of the 'pieces of paper' were electronically added, but was some of it real? Would they really litter somewhere like that? They need to clarify as it does appear somewhat reckless and hypocritical if they really did use so much paper needlessly.
T, Bristol, UK

I watched, electrified, as he tramped through all that litter and my lasting impression was, "Who did this and will they pick it up, every bit?" I didn't really catch what he was saying, though, but did notice the chap with the green hood going up the steps, then appearing again stage right.
Joan Miller, Basingstoke, Hampshire

Before anyone starts getting upset about those nasty Liberal Democrats spoiling the streets and countryside with all that waste paper, I should point out that most of it is clearly CGI.
Adam, Oxford

Wow, that's a lot of toilet paper going to waste.
Tony Quinn, Birmingham

Print Sponsor


But now comes the difficult part - making it work
Why has Eton College produced 18 British PMs?
Frantic talks on who will form the next government


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific