Page last updated at 13:23 GMT, Tuesday, 22 December 2009

SNP and Plaid threaten legal action over TV debates

SNP leader Alex Salmond
Alex Salmond says broadcasters have 'a duty of fairness'

The SNP and Plaid Cymru are refusing to rule out legal action over plans for three election debates between the main UK party leaders.

The BBC and Sky have promised to hold separate debates between the parties in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.

But the SNP and Plaid Cymru called their exclusion from the main UK-wide debates "undemocratic".

The UK Independence Party want to be included in parts of the debates. The Greens also want to be included.

SNP leader Alex Salmond says he will fight it in the courts if necessary.

Plaid leader Ieuan Wyn Jones said his party was also taking legal advice, arguing that it deserved to be part of a UK-wide debate because there could be a hung Parliament in which the nationalist parties would have role in deciding the next government.

Themed debates

He rejected the broadcasters' argument that the debate should be restricted to party leaders who could be the next prime minister.

He told BBC Radio 4's The World at One: "I don't think anybody, including Nick Clegg, thinks that the Lib Dems are likely to form the next government."

The first of the 90 minute programmes, with Labour Prime Minister Gordon Brown, Conservative leader David Cameron and Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg will be on ITV, the second on Sky and the third on the BBC.

ITV's Alastair Stewart will host the first, Sky's Adam Boulton the second and the BBC's David Dimbleby will host the third debate.

The format will be the same for each, although about half of each debate will be themed.

There will be separate debates held in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland among all the main parties, which will be broadcast on BBC Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland and across the UK on the BBC News Channel.

ITV, SKY and the BBC will host the debates

It is understood Sky News will hold debates in Scotland and Wales.


The SNP have pointed out that the courts prevented the BBC from broadcasting an interview with the then prime minister John Major during Scottish local elections in the 1990s, and Alex Salmond has made it clear that legal action could be on the cards again this time.

Mr Salmond said he would be seeking "guarantees of inclusion from the broadcasters, given their inescapable duty to ensure fairness and impartiality in election-related coverage in Scotland".

He added: "It is entirely unacceptable to Scotland as well as to the SNP for the broadcasters to exclude the party that forms the government of Scotland - and indeed is now leading in Westminster election polls."

'More entertaining'

And Plaid Cymru's Westminster leader Elfyn Llwyd said it was "completely undemocratic" as it would give the main parties an unfair advantage. He said he would complain to the Electoral Commission.

"Both Plaid Cymru and the SNP are in government in the respective devolved administrations and it is an insult that such important political voices are to be left out of such a historic event," he said.

Parties hoping to gain their first seat at Westminster are also unhappy with the format of the debates.

The UK Independence Party, which won more votes than Labour and the Lib Dems in the European elections, say they want to be included in segments of the debates covering the EU, direct democracy, immigration and the economy.

Leader Lord Pearson said: "Our position on all of those policies is very different from the three main parties and it would be very wrong for the British people not to be able to test us over our position in open debate

"Our presence would provide a real voice of opposition and make the debates far more entertaining."

A Green Party spokesman said: "Why on earth shouldn't [Green Party leader] Caroline Lucas be part of it, when she has obviously got so much to say and when a significant portion of the electorate support what she has to say?"

He added: "We are taking this as seriously as you might expect us to.

"We believe that with our proven track record of support and our distinctive agenda we should be part of any such debate."


The leaders of the three main parties at Westminster have each welcomed the chance to take part in what will be a first for a general election in Britain.

Speaking at a public meeting, Conservative leader David Cameron said: "I have always believed in live television debates.

"I think they can help enliven our democracy, I think they will help answer people's questions, I think they will crystallise the debate about the change this country needs."

Liberal Democrat leader Mr Clegg said he was "delighted".

"After a terrible year for politicians because of the expenses scandals, these debates will be an opportunity to start re-engaging people with politics... I hope an open, honest and vigorous debate will encourage more people to have their say at the ballot box."

The prime minister told the Daily Mirror: "I relish the opportunity provided by these debates to discuss the big choices the country faces.

"Choices like whether we lock in the recovery or whether we choke it off; whether we protect the NHS, schools and police or whether we put them at risk to pay for tax cuts for the wealthy few."

The election is widely expected to be held on Thursday 6 May although there has been speculation that it could be called for 25 March instead.

Print Sponsor

Televised election debates agreed
21 Dec 09 |  UK Politics
No leaders' debate place for SNP
21 Dec 09 |  Scotland
PM agrees to TV election debate
03 Oct 09 |  UK Politics
New pressure for TV leader debate
03 Sep 09 |  UK Politics
Blair's 'blue funk' over TV debate
18 Jan 01 |  Politics
Blair ducks TV debate
17 Jan 01 |  Politics

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific