Page last updated at 18:23 GMT, Thursday, 14 May 2009 19:23 UK

Brown suspends mortgage claim MP

Gordon Brown: 'Action has got to be taken'

Former minister Elliot Morley has been suspended from the Parliamentary Labour Party after claiming £16,000 expenses for a mortgage he had already paid off.

Prime Minister Gordon Brown said the decision was taken because of the "serious" nature of the allegations.

Mr Morley said the claim had been a "mistake" due to "sloppy accounting" and said he had paid the money back.

Conservative MP Andrew MacKay earlier resigned as aide to David Cameron over an "unacceptable" expenses claim.

Another Conservative MP, Douglas Hogg, is to repay £2,200 in expenses after admitting the clearing of his moat was "not positively excluded" from a claim as he had said.

Fellow Tory Greg Barker - the shadow climate change minister - has said he will pay capital gains tax on the sale of both properties he has owned in London since becoming an MP.

He said his claims and tax affairs had been "scrupulously within the rules" but he said "what counts" was "the trust and good opinion of my constituents".

It comes after the latest round of revelations in the Daily Telegraph about MPs' expenses.

Mr Brown said he was "very angry about what has happened" on MPs' expenses.

In a speech as he launched Labour's European election campaign, he said: "Where there is irregularity now it has got to be dealt with immediately. Where standards have been transgressed and the evidence has been shown to be there, action has got to be taken.

"Where disciplinary action is necessary, it will and will immediately be taken."

I deeply apologise for such sloppy accounting in a very loose and shambolic allowance system but there is nobody to blame but myself and I take full responsibility for this
Elliot Morley, Labour MP

He added: "If there are any other disciplinary cases where we have to take action we will take action immediately."

Mr Morley has not had the whip withdrawn, which would effectively expel him from the Parliamentary party - but Labour chief whip Nick Brown made it clear that he faced expulsion if he failed to clear his name.

He has also been suspended as the prime minister's climate envoy but remains chairman of the energy and climate select committee.

Nick Brown said his case would be discussed by the party's ruling National Executive Committee next Tuesday but told BBC News he wanted to give Mr Morley "breathing space" while the allegations were investigated.

'Sloppy accounting'

The chief whip said Mr Morley had first come to him "a week or two weeks ago" to say there might be a problem with his expenses, but he denied he should have acted sooner, as he did not know the full details at that stage.

Mr Morley, who is MP for Scunthorpe, has referred himself to Parliamentary Standards Commissioner John Lyon in an effort to clear his name.

According to the Telegraph, he claimed £800 a month for a Scunthorpe property for 18 months after the mortgage ended.

In a statement, Mr Morley said he did his accounts in "yearly bundles" and he had "simply let the established payment run as it has for some years".

We've been slugging this matter out for days and not got anywhere - we've failed as a political class
Nick Clegg, Lib Dem leader

He added: "I deeply apologise for such sloppy accounting in a very loose and shambolic allowance system but there is nobody to blame but myself and I take full responsibility for this," he added.

The Telegraph also alleges Mr Morley rented out a London flat designated as his main residence to another Labour MP, Ian Cawsey, a close friend and former special adviser.

Mr Cawsey named the property as his second home, allowing him to claim £1,000 a month to cover the rent which he was charged by Mr Morley.

In November 2007, the newspaper claims, Mr Morley "flipped" his designated second home from his Scunthorpe property to his London home and for four months the two men claimed expenses on the same property.

Tory aide quits

The Commons fees office stopped the arrangement. Mr Cawsey said he had been unaware of Mr Morley's financial arrangements.

Mr Morley issued a lengthy explanation of his arrangement with Mr Cawsey in which he denied any wrongdoing and said he used the money from his Labour colleague to reduce his claim to the taxpayer.

Chief Whip Nick Brown has also spoken to Labour MP Fabian Hamilton, who claimed thousands of pounds in second home allowances for his family home in Leeds while listing his mother's property in London as his main residence.

People in Elliot Morley's constituency react to his expenses revelations

The Leeds North East MP said those claims covered a two-year period while he was looking after his mother in London. He told the BBC his mother was dying and he had to spend "a huge amount of time" at the house where his family had joined him.

"The Inland Revenue were quite satisfied that I'd spent more time in that house over those two years and I was paying the costs of maintaining that property as well, a big four bedroom property," he said.

"So it was not unreasonable to ask for help with my other home which was in Leeds."

Nick Brown said the expenses scandal had done "extensive damage to the reputation of Parliament" - but he accused the Conservatives of blocking a cross-party agreement on reforming expenses and of "trying to play politics for all it is worth" over the issue.

He said there would not be wholesale reform until Sir Christopher Kelly, chairman of the committee on standards in public life, completed his report later in the year.

Tory leader David Cameron is setting up his own scrutiny panel to investigate Tory expense claims.

I am utterly appalled, disgusted and horrified by this fiasco.
Teresa Ross, Eastleigh

The first casualty of the clampdown was his own Parliamentary aide, Andrew MacKay, who quit his post over what the party said were "unacceptable" expenses claims.

He claimed the second home allowance on his London address, while his wife, Tory MP Julie Kirkbride, claimed it for another home.

Between them they claimed 98.5% of the total allowance available to them since 2004.

He has said he will pay back an amount decided by the Tory panel, adding: "Due to an error of judgement in accepting advice from the fees office I have let a lot of people down."

Mr Cameron has said he will seriously consider Sir Christopher Kelly's recommendations when they are published in the autumn but has urged Gordon Brown to show leadership and push through reforms of the system now.

Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg has written to Mr Cameron and Mr Brown to say it is time all the parties agree to accept the Kelly inquiry recommendations in full when they come out.

He said: "We've been slugging this matter out for days and not got anywhere," adding: "We've failed as a political class."

He said the latest developments in the expenses saga were "a further deterioration of trust in public politics".

Name Party Repayment
Total 305,499
Sir John Butterfill CON 60,000
Phil Hope LAB 41,709
Jonathan Djanogly CON 25,000
Margaret Moran LAB 22,500
Elliot Morley LAB 16,800
Bill Cash CON 15,000
Hazel Blears LAB 13,332
David Chaytor LAB 13,000
Sir Alan Haselhurst CON 12,000
Greg Barker CON 10,000
Michael Gove CON 7,567
Mark Hendrick LAB 6,850
John Bercow CON 6,500
Ronnie Campbell LAB 6,000
Hilary Armstrong LAB 5,500
Alan Duncan CON 5,000
Richard Younger-Ross LIB 4,333
Peter Luff CON 3,185
Tony McNulty LAB 3,055
Lady Sylvia Hermon UUP 2,730
Mark Lazarowicz LAB 2,675
Andrew Lansley CON 2,600
David Kidney LAB 2,450
Ed Vaizey CON 2,268
Douglas Hogg CON 2,200
Oliver Letwin CON 2,145
Linda Gilroy LAB 1,891
Gerald Kaufman LAB 1,851
Sir Menzies Campbell LIB 1,490
Shahid Malik LAB 1,050
charity donation
Julia Goldsworthy LIB 1,005
David Cameron CON 680
Alistair Darling LAB 668
George Osborne CON 440
Geoff Hoon LAB 384
Stewart Jackson CON 304
Alistair Burt CON 229
Fraser Kemp LAB 212
Gordon Brown LAB 153
Alan Beith LIB 140
David Willetts CON 135
Chris Huhne LIB 119
Michael Ancram CON 98.50
Nick Clegg LIB 80
Diana Johnson LAB 65
Lembit Opik LIB 40
James Clappison CON 38
Andrew George LIB 20
Cheryl Gillan CON 4.50
Mike Penning CON 3

Print Sponsor

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2020 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific