Page last updated at 16:13 GMT, Wednesday, 22 October 2008 17:13 UK

Brown urges Osborne investigation

Gordon Brown calls for an investigation into the claims

Gordon Brown has called for an investigation into claims George Osborne tried to solicit a 50,000 donation from Oleg Deripaska.

The Tories firmly deny the allegations against the shadow chancellor.

Party leader David Cameron said Mr Osborne was "right" not to ask for money from the Russian billionaire.

But speaking at prime minister's questions, Mr Brown said: "This is a very serious matter indeed and I hope it is investigated by the authorities."

'Absurd fantasy'

Pressed after prime minister's questions about which allegations Mr Brown had been referring to in his comments, Downing Street said those made "over the past 24 hours" but would give no more details.

I am not sure which authorities Gordon thought he was talking about - the only one I can think of is the Conservative Party
Tony Wright
Labour MP

The No 10 spokesman also refused to be drawn on which "authorities" would carry out an investigation, saying "whichever authorities are appropriate".

The Electoral Commission told BBC Radio 4's The World at One it would not be investigating the claims as "soliciting a donation is not an offence".

Labour MP Tony Wright, chairman of the public administration select committee, also dismissed calls for a probe.

"Gordon obviously thinks it was a serious matter, and I suppose in a sense it is a serious matter," he said.

"But we are not talking about corruption here, there was no corruption. We're not talking about law-breaking, there is no law-breaking. What there is is a massive misjudgement."

Conservative MP John Redwood said Lord Mandelson should be forced to answer questions about his presence on Mr Deripaska's yacht and he rejected claims Mr Osborne had shown poor judgement.

"There is no crime committed and this is just an absurd media fantasy," he told World at One.

But former Conservative Party chairman Lord Tebbit told the BBC that if people "sleep with dogs they get fleas" but added "I don't think George Osborne would be daft enough to ask for money".

A spokeswoman for the Parliamentary Standards Commissioner said he had not received any complaints about Mr Osborne. A complaint is required before the watchdog can look into the conduct of an MP.

Mr Osborne has emphatically denied seeking a donation from Mr Deripaska while staying with long-time friend, the financier Nat Rothschild, in Corfu in August.

Overseas donation

Mr Rothschild says the shadow chancellor did discuss a donation in front of a witness at his home.

Mr Osborne has also denied claims that he asked about ways to get round a ban on overseas donations to UK parties.

Speaking outside his home on Wednesday morning, Conservative leader Mr Cameron said: "What matters is what you do and what you say and George Osborne was right not to ask for any money. The Conservative Party was right not to accept any money.

"And I think we have been right to set out in full all the meetings and everything that took place and others should do the same."


But Mr Rothschild has said he will not "back down" and is prepared to defend his claims in court.

He alleged he had discussed the idea of a donation via Mr Deripaska's UK firm, LDV Ltd, three times on 24 August - with Mr Osborne and Tory fundraiser Andrew Feldman.

He said the first discussion, held in his Corfu home, had been witnessed by a New York fund manager, James Goodwin.

He said Mr Goodwin also "recalled" that the subject of a donation "arose briefly" later when the men were guests on Mr Deripaska's yacht but the "conversation gained no traction".

'More questions'

Mr Rothschild said the subject was raised again with Mr Osborne later that evening, in which he said the shadow chancellor was "interested in whether and how such a donation could be secured".

Furthermore, he added that during a conversation with Mr Feldman in the middle of September, he was "left with the impression that the Conservative Party remained interested in pursuing it".

This is a fuss over a deal that never was
Peter, Cambridge, UK

Mr Osborne said on Tuesday he had not sought a donation, saying that the issue was raised by Mr Rothschild.

He said: "People make suggestions all the time about donations to the Conservative Party, but we are always clear and rigorous [in assessing these]."

The Lib Dems said a "lot more questions" had to be answered about the affair and called for a parliamentary inquiry.

Mr Brown repeatedly alluded to Mr Osborne's "judgement" during prime minister's questions session but it was left to veteran left-winger Dennis Skinner, a frequent critic of Mr Osborne, to raise the issue head-on.

'Put to rest'

As the half-hour session came to an end, he urged the PM to assure him he would never "cadge money" from Russian billionaires .

It was in response to that question that Mr Brown said he hoped to see an investigation.

Labour MP Denis MacShane has written to Mr Osborne, asking him to clarify what happened in Corfu.

He said that this could allow "the matter to be put to rest".

But a Conservative spokesman said this and the prime minister's comments were a "desperate attempt to keep the story going".

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific