Page last updated at 19:29 GMT, Friday, 12 September 2008 20:29 UK

Whip sacked over leader bid call

Siobhain McDonagh: 'I think we need a leadership election'

A junior member of the government has been sacked after breaking ranks to call for a challenge to Prime Minister Gordon Brown as Labour leader.

Assistant whip Siobhain McDonagh said she wanted a debate about the party's future and a "huge number" of other Labour MPs also wanted a contest.

A government spokesman said she had always been "anti-Gordon" but the Tories said Labour was in "civil war".

She has been replaced in the whips office by Brent South MP Dawn Butler.

Ms McDonagh - who was the only member of the government not to nominate Mr Brown for the party leadership last year - said she wanted a debate about the future of the party and the country.

Debate call

The Mitcham and Morden MP said "everybody" in government was talking about the leadership issue and she wanted such discussions to be out in the open.

"It's about time we let party members and people involved in the Labour Party and the wider community in on that debate," she told the BBC News Channel.

I think Gordon Brown is a really good man who has the best of intentions - I just think that being prime minster is a shockingly hard job
Siobhain McDonald

"I think we need to clear the air. I think whoever wants to stand for leader of the Labour Party should do so and we should have a good debate about the direction of the party and the government."

She insisted that she did not have a particular candidate in mind.

But she told BBC Radio 4's PM programme that "a huge number of Labour MPs want a leadership election".

'Shockingly hard'

She refused to say whether she would back Gordon Brown or another candidate in a contest.

Asked if Mr Brown had done a good job since taking over, she said: "I think Gordon Brown is a really good man who has the best of intentions. I just think that being prime minster is a shockingly hard job."

The Labour Party is quite clearly degenerating into a state of civil war
Chris Grayling
Shadow cabinet member

Asked whether she felt he was "shockingly bad" at it, she said not.

Ms McDonagh is so far the only member of the government to call publicly for a leadership contest.

She added: "If I could have found an easier way, or a quieter way, to do this then I would have done it.

"But everyone's saying, 'You first.' I didn't want to be in a position where I'd look back in five years' time and think I could have done the right thing but didn't do it."

She is among a small group of Labour MPs to have sought details about the nomination process for a contest.

She told PM she had written to Labour's general secretary in confidence to ask for nomination papers but had been forced to go public with her concerns after being contacted by a journalist.

'Early election'

Labour confirmed the party had received letters from a "small number" of MPs asking why no nomination papers for leader were issued ahead of the party conference.

It would take 70 MPs to trigger a potential leadership contest.

Labour MP Emily Thornberry mounted a defence of Mr Brown's premiership on PM, saying the public would not "respect" Ms McDonagh for her call.

And the reason no alternative candidate had come forward to challenge Mr Brown was that he was "best qualified" to steer the country through difficult economic times, she said.

But Chris Grayling, for the Conservatives, said: "The Labour Party is quite clearly degenerating into a state of civil war.

"For a prime minister to have one of his own whips calling for a leadership contest is unprecedented.

"At a time when Britain faces massive economic challenges it is profoundly damaging to have a government in such disarray. We need an early election to get the change Britain so desperately needs."

'Hammer blow' warning

In a separate development, 12 backbench Labour MPs, including six former ministers, have urged the leadership to develop "a convincing new narrative" which has to be more than "a series of policy initiatives" in order to restore Labour's fortunes.

In a joint article for New Labour magazine Progress, they say Labour has "no explanation yet" as to how it will "steer the economy through the troubled waters ahead".

And they claim that "one-off taxes and pay-outs, no matter how justified in their own terms, do not amount to a strategy", adding there is a "yawning chasm" which the Labour party needs to fill or the government will suffer a "hammer blow".

The piece is signed by Janet Anderson, Karen Buck, Patricia Hewitt, George Howarth, Eric Joyce, Sally Keeble, Stephen Ladyman, Martin Linton, Shona McIsaac, Margaret Moran, Tom Levitt, and Paddy Tipping.

Progress insists the article it is not linked to Ms McDonagh's call for a leadership contest but it will add to pressure on Gordon Brown ahead of Labour's conference later this month.

Profile: Siobhain McDonagh
12 Sep 08 |  UK Politics
Brown pledge to 'rethink' policy
09 Sep 08 |  UK Politics
PM: Britain will be stronger
08 Sep 08 |  UK Politics
Cameron: Back Brown or sack him
07 Sep 08 |  UK Politics

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2016 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific