Page last updated at 15:56 GMT, Wednesday, 2 April 2008 16:56 UK

Cable anger over Queen reprimand

Vince Cable
Vince Cable was prevented from asking a Commons question

Lib Dem deputy leader Vince Cable has attacked "ridiculous" Commons procedures after he was banned from asking a question about the Queen.

Mr Cable mentioned the Monarch in a question on the economy to Harriet Harman, who was standing in for Gordon Brown at prime ministers questions.

But he was prevented from completing it by Speaker Michael Martin.

Mr Cable said it was "ridiculous" MPs could not mention the Queen in passing "without prior permission".

In the Commons, Mr Cable was cheered by MPs when he rose to ask the first of his permitted questions to Ms Harman.

He said: "It was reported this week that Her Majesty the Queen had cancelled her diamond wedding celebrations because it was judged to be inappropriate to engage in extravagance at a time of economic gloom and recession.

"Do you share my view that this demonstrates Her Majesty's unerring instincts for the public mood, or does the Government think she was overreacting?"

'Constitutional reform'

But Speaker Martin would not let the question be answered.

He ruled: "Order! You shouldn't discuss Her Majesty the Queen. Perhaps you can try another question. He has used one up. He can try another one."

I think he made a mistake, but people make mistakes at prime minister's questions
Sir Menzies Campbell
Former Lib Dem leader

Mr Cable said he was very happy for the Labour deputy leader to "return to the issue of economic gloom and recession and whether you share that assessment."

Outside the Commons he said: "It is absolutely ridiculous that in a supposedly modern democracy Members of Parliament cannot even mention the Head of State in passing without prior permission.

"This is yet more proof of the major constitutional reform needed to drag Westminster into the 21st century."

Commenting on Mr Cable's decision to mention the Queen, former Lib Dem leader Sir Menzies Campbell said: "I think he made a mistake, but people make mistakes at prime minister's questions."

He added: "I'm sure he will be back at his pungent best."

It is a Commons convention that MPs do not discuss the Queen.

'Sent to the Tower'

According to Erskine May, the guide to parliamentary practice, "the irregular use of the Queen's name to influence a decision of the House is unconstitutional in principle and inconsistent with the independence of Parliament".

It adds: "Any attempt to use her name in debate to influence the judgement of Parliament is immediately checked and censured."

It says MPs have been reprimanded "or even sent to the Tower" for treasonable or seditious language "or disrespectful use of Her Majesty's name".

'Museum piece'

Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg has vowed to highlight what he sees as antiquated Parliamentary procedure as part of his campaign for democratic reform.

He has said Parliament "is fast becoming a museum piece - a 19th-century home for our 21st-century political elite".

Last month Lib Dem frontbencher Ed Davey was thrown out of the Commons for protesting against the Speaker's decision not to allow a vote on a referendum Britain's continued membership of the EU.

Fellow Lib Dem MPs walked out of the chamber in solidarity during debate on the Lisbon Treaty.

Mr Clegg told delegates at the party's spring conference in Liverpool they could expect to see further such protests.




SEE ALSO
Harman vs Hague
02 Apr 08 |  UK Politics
Expect more protests, says Clegg
08 Mar 08 |  UK Politics
Pub chain fails to see Cable joke
08 Mar 08 |  UK Politics
Point-by-point: Question time
02 Apr 08 |  UK Politics


FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

BBC navigation

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific