[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 29 March 2007, 11:25 GMT 12:25 UK
Will Home Office split end problems?
Analysis
By Nick Assinder
Political correspondent, BBC News website

Home Secretary John Reid is investing a huge amount of his own political capital in the decision to split his "dysfunctional" department in two.

From left: Gordon Brown, John Reid, Lord Falconer
John Reid is accused of rushing through reform
He believes the current Home Office is far too big and unwieldy and that separating out responsibility for justice and for security into two distinct departments ministers will be able to get a proper grip on them.

Specifically, as he told MPs in a sometimes heated Commons debate, he believes the terrorism threat requires a powerful new unit within the Home Office able to "focus" its attention on combating that threat rather than being distracted by issues of justice like sentencing and probation.

His critics, however, have warned that the effect of this split will actually be to exacerbate the problem at the heart of the Home Office's woes - that there is inadequate co-ordination between the different sections.

If the left hand already does not know what the right is doing, sticking them on different people's arms will only make matters worse, they claim.

The first row came after the Tories forced Mr Reid to the Commons to make an emergency statement on the proposal amid claims the Home Secretary was revealing it on the day MPs left the Commons for a two week Easter break, so avoiding proper debate.

Arguable case

And there were serious concerns being raised over the proposal from all sides.

Home Office sign
Home Office was deemed not fit for purpose
Former Home Secretary Charles Clarke went so far as to brand the move "irresponsible", which led to a slap down from Mr Reid, accusing him of having got things wrong during his time in the job.

Shadow home secretary David Davis said the move would distract the departments for months and end up with even more problems with crime, immigration and security.

"Because of the way it has been done, the creation of a department of justice and a department of security will leave public security undermined, and a justice system overwhelmed," he said.

He also repeated the suspicions voiced elsewhere that the decision was a botched job after a row between ministers over who controlled what.

The Liberal Democrat's Nick Clegg also highlighted what is believed to be the underlying politics of the decision, claiming it is being rushed through by Mr Reid and Tony Blair before Gordon Brown - thought to be lukewarm, at best, over the proposal - becomes prime minister.

Big idea

He also noted the fact that an inquiry into the 7 July bombings had been rejected on the grounds it would distract attention from the fight against terrorism.

Would not, he asked, the time and effort taken in arranging the department's split be greater than holding a public inquiry would have taken up.

There is a suspicion already running around Westminster that Mr Brown may want to take an entirely different approach to the Home Office.

David Blunkett
Mr Blunkett opposes Home Office split

It has previously been suggested, for example, that he wanted the anti-terrorism effort concentrated under the cabinet office.

Since Mr Reid's split plan was originally floated former Labour home secretaries have confirmed they also considered such proposals while in post, but rejected them.

Jack Straw said he opposed the idea when he ran the department, saying he felt he could cope with the department's broad range.

But he said he had changed his mind as a result of the huge growth of terrorism and counter-terrorism as an issue since the terrorist attacks on 11 September.

His successor, David Blunkett, also dismissed such suggestions and still opposes them, warning the "Balkanisation of government" - with departments led by a number of ministers - would inevitably concentrate power into the hands of the prime minister and chancellor.

But this has now become Mr Reid's big idea and, if he remains as home secretary, as expected, under Gordon Brown's likely premiership he will feel the full effects of its success or failure.




VOTE RESULTS
Will splitting the Home Office make a difference?
Yes
 31.60% 
No
 53.31% 
Not sure
 15.09% 
12206 Votes Cast
Results are indicative and may not reflect public opinion

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific