Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

Front Page



UK Politics







Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Low Graphics

Wednesday, September 15, 1999 Published at 21:28 GMT 22:28 UK

UK Politics

Byers rejects arms hypocrisy claim

The UK has cancelled further Hawk exports to Indonesia

Trade Secretary Stephen Byers has defended the government against allegations of hypocrisy after it emerged his department had been helping to fund sales of warplanes to Indonesia.

The BBC's Michael Fairbairn: "Even the Government's friends are critical"
MPs expressed outrage when it was revealed that £130m of taxpayers' money had been used over the past year to assist the Indonesian Government to continue with the purchase of British-built Hawk jets.

However, Mr Byers insisted that he had done nothing wrong and rejected claims that the government's commitment to pursuing an "ethical" foreign policy was is in tatters.

He has also defended his approval of a loan to help a UK company working on a vast public works contract in Indonesia.

East Timor
The row comes as United Nations troops prepare to go to East Timor to deal with the carnage caused by pro-Indonesian militias following the independence referendum in the territory.

The money provided by the Department of Trade and Industry was used to reschedule loans to allow the Indonesians to buy Hawk jets from British Aerospace and also gave financial help to UK firms working for the regime in Jakarta.

Stephen Byers defends his actions
Mr Byers said he had been simply honouring credit agreements set up by the previous Conservative administration.

That policy had now been changed and all fresh applications for credit from Jakarta had been refused this year, he added.

"We have acted properly in all these matters," Mr Byers said.

Asked whether the government's ethical foreign policy was still intact, he said: "It is an ethical foreign policy which means that we changed the criteria by which we judge these matters.

"That has enabled me to reject applications for credit for arms."

'Huge hypocrisy'

But the Conservatives accused the government of "huge hypocrisy."

Tory leader William Hague said that the government's claim of an ethical foreign policy was in ruins

"We've been saying that we should suspend non-humanitarian aid to Indonesia but actually the government all the time have been extending additional credit for the purchase of arms.

"No wonder they've been rather cagey about that. I don't know where their ethical foreign policy stands now, it seems to have disappeared altogether."

'MPs want answers'

The Labour chair of the Commons Trade and Industry Committee, Martin O'Neill, said the Foreign Secretary, Robin Cook, would face some tough questions on arms sales to Indonesia when Parliament returned from its summer break.

[ image: The Indonesian military has been accused of colluding with murdering militiamen]
The Indonesian military has been accused of colluding with murdering militiamen
He said he believed his committee "was entitled to some answers."

Mr O'Neill said he thought governments, including the current administration, paid more attention to the arms lobby than ethical considerations.

Senior Labour backbencher Ann Clwyd, a longtime opponent of arms sales to Indonesia, also castigated ministers.

"It was clear for some time that Indonesia was a human rights abuser. When we came into government we made clear that there would be an ethical dimension to our foreign policy yet we continued to supply arms,'' she said.

Menzies Campbell: Ethical concerns must be implemented across government
The Liberal Democrats foreign affairs spokesman Menzies Campbell said more effort should be made across all government departments to ensure ethical considerations drive government policy.

The UK has already suspended all arms sales to Indonesia as a result of the violence in East Timor.

'Loan helped poorest'

However, some Labour MPs have also demanded an investigation into the claims that Mr Byers overrode top civil servants' concerns to authorise a loan of around £1m to a British engineering company working in Indonesia only weeks before the militias began massacring civilians in East Timor.

The decision, taken on 19 July, was on top of a £20m loan already advanced to Va Tech Reyrolle Projects, to help them build power transmission lines in Indonesia, it was reported.

Mr Byers said: "I took the decision because the application, which was for less than £1m, would enable the completion of a project to supply electricity to central Java, helping some of the poorest people of Indonesia.

"To suggest that I have overruled senior civil servants is to deliberately misunderstand the Export Credit Guarantee Department's rules and ministers' responsibilities."

However, according to the Guardian which reported the claims the National Audit Office is considering investigating the affair.

Advanced options | Search tips

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©

UK Politics Contents

A-Z of Parliament
Talking Politics
Vote 2001

Relevant Stories

14 Sep 99†|†Asia-Pacific
Australia to lead Timor force

15 Sep 99†|†UK Politics
Protests at arms show

14 Sep 99†|†UK Politics
Robertson defends Indonesia arms sales

11 Sep 99†|†UK Politics
Indonesia to receive UK jets

03 Sep 99†|†e-cyclopedia
Arms trading: How to buy a Hawk jet

Internet Links

Indonesian Armed Forces

Department of Trade and Industry

East Timor Action Network

British Aerospace

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

In this section

Livingstone hits back

Catholic monarchy ban 'to continue'

Hamilton 'would sell mother'

Straw on trial over jury reform

Blairs' surprise over baby

Conceived by a spin doctor?

Baby cynics question timing

Blair in new attack on Livingstone

Week in Westminster

Chris Smith answers your questions

Reid quits PR job

Children take over the Assembly

Two sword lengths

Industry misses new trains target