[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Friday, 25 March, 2005, 14:11 GMT
Secret Iraq legal advice probed
Royal Marines in southern Iraq
The government refuses to publish the full legal advice on the Iraq war
The decision to prevent disclosure of Attorney General Lord Goldsmith's legal advice on the Iraq war is being studied by the Information Commissioner.

Richard Thomas received complaints when details were withheld despite requests under the Freedom of Information Act.

The independent watchdog is expected to study the sensitive advice and decide if secrecy is in the public interest.

A Foreign Office lawyer's resignation letter suggests the attorney deemed the war illegal until the eve of conflict.

'Illegal war'

The revelations came in a censored part of Elizabeth Wilmshurst's letter, obtained by Channel 4 News under the Act.

It suggests Lord Goldsmith QC originally believed a new UN resolution was needed to make the war legal.

It must be right to maintain confidentiality between lawyer and client...in this case, the Attorney General and the government
The Lord Chancellor

But he reportedly wrote an equivocal letter to Tony Blair on 7 March 2003 saying the war might be illegal and it was safer to get a new resolution.

On 17 March he said the invasion was legal under previous UN resolution, with no new agreement needed.

Ms Wilmshurst quit two days before the war because she believed the invasion was a "crime of aggression".

The ensuing row led to Jack Straw defending Lord Goldsmith's advice in the Commons on Thursday, when the foreign secretary denied the letter showed the attorney general had changed his mind just before hostilities began.

Before 7 March: Lord Goldsmith believed war not legal without new UN resolution, claims Elizabeth Wilmshurst
7 March: Lord Goldsmith tells Tony Blair it would be safer to have second resolution
17 March: Parliamentary answer from Lord Goldsmith says war legal without new resolution
18 March: Tony Blair makes case for war ahead of MPs voting for military action
20 March: Invasion of Iraq begins

Mr Thomas, who oversees the act's operation, said he had received a number of complaints from individuals and newspapers after ministers refused applications under the new act to publish the legal advice.

"We will be going through a process of examining those complaints," he said.

Mr Thomas added that so far he had received about eight complaints about the government's decision, but he would not be drawn on the timing of his investigations.

He added: "We have recently signed a memorandum of understanding with Lord Falconer on behalf of all government departments.

"It sets out the basis for co-operation in the interests of efficiency between my office and government departments.

"The departments will provide my office with all relevant information, including everything that has been withheld or redacted and we undertake to keep it appropriately secure and not to release it to third parties."
Put the request in writing
Reply should be offered within 20 working days
Explanation should be offered for any refusals
Information may be withheld for reasons including privacy or national security
Refer to information commissioner if explanation is unsatisfactory
Organisation can be compelled to release the information
Appeals can be made to information tribunal

Ministers announced on 25 January that the full text of the attorney general's advice would not be made public under the act.

Government departments received about 40 requests for the document but ministers said it was protected by legal professional privilege.

The Lord Chancellor, Lord Falconer of Thoroton QC, said in January: "It must be right to maintain confidentiality between lawyer and client - whether it is a solicitor and someone buying a house, a barrister and someone appearing in court or, as in this case, the Attorney General and the government."

Richard Thomas explains the scope of his inquiry

Profile: Lord Goldsmith
24 Mar 05 |  Politics
Iraq war haunts UK prime minister
24 Mar 05 |  Politics
Wilmshurst resignation letter
23 Mar 05 |  Politics
Iraq war advice secrecy defended
03 Jan 05 |  Politics
Iraq 'legal' despite flawed case
15 Jul 04 |  Politics
Goldsmith: 'I was not leant on'
01 Mar 05 |  Politics

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific