[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Wednesday, 7 July, 2004, 17:03 GMT 18:03 UK
'Booze cruise' legal threat to UK
French Supermarket
Stocking up on alcohol in France is a popular British custom
Brussels has accused British Customs of disproportionate tactics in tackling people bringing excessive amounts of alcohol and tobacco into the UK.

The UK Government has been told it has two months to satisfy the commission its approach is not in breach of EU or face legal action.

They say people can bring in any amount of booze and tobacco for personal use.

UK Customs have been seizing alcohol and tobacco and confiscating vehicles if they think goods will be sold.

Court action?

The Treasury says it is loosing huge amounts of tax revenue as people bring in cigarettes and alcohol from across the Channel, where duty tends to be lower.

We fully support British shoppers' rights to bring back as much tobacco and alcohol as they like from the Continent for their own consumption
Treasury spokesman
The commission has already formally told the government to justify the tactics.

Now it has gone further and warned that Britain could be taken to the European Court of Justice for breaching EU rules on the free movement of good and cross-border shopping.

A statement said: "The commission has decided to send the UK a formal request to amend its policies relating to excise duties and cross-border shopping for tobacco and alcohol.

"The commission's request concerns the policy of seizing goods and sometimes cars even for minor offences.

Too much?

"The commission considers that such seizures are disproportionate to the gravity of the offence in some situations and represent an obstacle to the free movement of goods subject to excise duties in the internal market."

"If there is no satisfactory response to the reasoned opinion within two months the commission may refer the matter to the Court of Justice."

European Commissioner Frits Bolkestein, who overseas taxation and customs, has said: "Cross-border shopping is a fundamental right under EU law and should not be regarded as a form of tax evasion - even if it does give rise to revenue losses for the UK Exchequer."

A spokesman for the Treasury said the UK Government would not be "lectured" by someone "pretending to be a friend of the British tourist".


"We fully support British shoppers' rights to bring back as much tobacco and alcohol as they like from the Continent for their own consumption," he said.

"Our sanctions regime is designed to protect those rights while deterring people from breaking the law - and it is entirely proportionate to a smuggling problem that funds organised crime and costs the British taxpayer 4bn a year."

The spokesman added that the commission "wheels out this same spin twice a year - pretending to be the friend of the British tourist - once before the summer holidays and once before the Christmas booze cruises.

"It is a cynical worn-out ploy to obtain a good day's coverage in the British press, and everyone should see through it for what it is."

The BBC's Stephen Sackur
"Last year Customs confiscated more than 8,000 vehicles"

Customs 'unfair' to day-trippers
13 Nov 03  |  Business
Customs deny defying High Court
13 Aug 02  |  UK News
Customs 'victim' praises decision
31 Jul 02  |  England

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific