[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 1 July 2004, 21:40 GMT 22:40 UK
Iran rejects UK servicemen claims
British servicemen sit aboard an aircraft at Mahshahr, Iran
The servicemen have returned to British units in Iraq
Iran has rejected claims by eight British servicemen that they were "forcibly escorted" into its territorial waters before being taken captive.

The men maintain they were operating in Iraq's waters and had not strayed into Iran's, UK defence secretary Geoff Hoon said.

But Iran's foreign ministry claims British officials have admitted the boats entered its waters by mistake.

The servicemen were held for three

days, sparking a stand-off with the UK.

Foreign Secretary Jack Straw expressed concern about the row and urged the Iranian authorities to return confiscated British equipment.

He said: "We would be greatly assisted if and when we get back the global positioning equipment because that would tell us for certain where they were," he said.

In a statement released by the Ministry of Defence on Wednesday, Mr Hoon said the MoD was looking into the servicemen's story.

He also expressed concern about "the blindfolding of the men" during their captivity and added the UK had made representations to ... Iran."

We do not expect a recurrence of this type of incident
Geoff Hoon
Defence Secretary

Shadow foreign secretary Michael Ancram described the alleged treatment of the servicemen as "absolutely outrageous" and demanded a "full apology" from Iranian authorities if the claims are true and called for a Commons statement.

But Commons leader Peter Hain on Thursday rejected those calls on the handling of this "very sensitive" issue.

Iranian foreign ministry spokesman Hamid Reza Asefi said he was surprised at the content of Mr Hoon's statement, as officials had already explained what had happened.


"During the hand-over of the British servicemen in Tehran, the British charge d'affaires signed the minutes of the meeting that he attended with the relevant Iranian officials.

"The minutes admitted that the British boats entered the Iranian waters by mistake," Mr Asefi said in a statement issued through Iran's official news agency.

And, he added, Mr Straw, during a telephone conversation with Iran's Foreign Minister, Kamal Kharrazi, had also said the British soldiers entered Iranian waters by mistake.

Responding to that issue the foreign secretary said later: "The sequence is that initially we thought, and a British Army spokesman said, that the servicemen had strayed into Iranian waters by mistake. In their debrief, I understand the crews have said that they were on the Iraqi side of the border."

By seizing the men Iran was probably sending a signal to the new regime in Iraq as much as it was to Britain
The BBC's David Loyn

The BBC's David Loyn said it will be "very hard" getting to the truth of this.

The exact line of the border in the Shatt Al-Arab is disputed between Iran and Iraq, and was one of the causes of their long war in the 1980s which left approximately one million dead.

"By seizing the men Iran was probably sending a signal to the new regime in Iraq as much as it was to Britain, wanting to remind them of Iran's strength and that the border remains unfinished business between the two countries," Loyn said.

Iranian forces are currently massing for a routine military exercise along Iran's land border with Iraq further north of the waterway.

He added that while the British denial that its servicemen had strayed into Iranian waters is likely to prolong the return of its navigational equipment, it is the equipment itself that can ultimately retrace the exact movements of the team.

120 miles of tidal waterway
Formed by Tigris and Euphrates rivers
Subject to 1639 Persian-Ottoman treaty
Southern stretch forms border between Iraq and Iran
River is vital trade route for both countries
Control of river one of disputes causing Iran-Iraq war in 1980

Tony Blair's official spokesman said inquiries were continuing into the exact circumstances but Britain believed the sailors had been engaged in a routine operation.

Asked whether it had been premature to apologise to Iran, he said the priority had been to get the men home.

It would be for Britain's Ambassador in Tehran to raise any issues direct with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, he said.

For the Lib Dems Paul Keetch said: "This is potentially a new twist to the story. The GPS [global positioning system] equipment has yet to be returned. When it is, it may well shed more light on the matter."

Mr Hoon said the Iranians had failed to comply with Tuesday's deadline to return equipment carried by the men including three boats, radios and navigational equipment, weapons and ammunition.

The BBC's David Loyn
"The Tories want more pressure put on Iran"

Hoon: Statement in full
30 Jun 04 |  UK Politics
Iran releases British servicemen
24 Jun 04 |  Middle East
Iran power tussle over UK sailors
22 Jun 04 |  Middle East
Patrolling the border waterways
21 Jun 04 |  Middle East
Timeline: UK-Iran relations
22 Jun 04 |  Middle East
Country profile: Iran
15 Jan 04 |  Country profiles

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific