Friday, May 21, 1999 Published at 17:36 GMT 18:36 UK
MSPs demand rethink on parliament
Backbench MSPs have attacked the Holyrood proposals
A Liberal Democrat MSP and a nationalist counterpart have joined forces to demand a rethink over plans for a new Scottish Parliament building.
Lib Dem Donald Gorrie, a fierce critic of his party's coalition deal with Labour, and Margo MacDonald of the Scottish National Party say the planned new building at Holyrood in Edinburgh is already hugely over budget.
The pair say their motion demanding that the parliament building be made an "all-party issue, not a party or government issue" is attracting support from MSPs.
The Scottish Office, said Mr Gorrie, had the option of using the Royal High School building at Calton Hill and government offices at St Andrew's House, all for under £50m.
"Instead, it chose a new site at Holyrood, where the building will cost at least £83.6m plus the cost of roadworks not yet calculated.
"The renovation of St Andrew's House, which was included in the costing of the Calton Hill proposal, but is a necessary add-on for the Holyrood scheme is costing £20m."
Mr Gorrie said temporary use of the Assembly Hall on the Mound is £7.7m.
"So the total cost of this choice is not the £50m promised but £113m and rising."
He added: "This is an example of bad politics at its worst. It was a bad decision by ministerial diktat, against the great weight of informed opinion and with no discussion by Parliament."
Margo MacDonald, a Lothians region MSP, said the Parliament may have to consider another site because the architect commissioned for the Holyrood building, Enric Miralles, appears to have altered the agreed design.
A Scottish Office spokesman said MSPs would be entitled to take on issues surrounding the parliament site and could ultimately decide to go elsewhere if they wished to do so.
But he pointed out that current leasing arrangements, and in particular those with the Church of Scotland over the temporary home of the parliament, would have to be taken into account.
And a government source expressed surprise at the opposition to the site, given the establishment of an all-party steering group on the parliament prior to the elections.
He said: "The party leaders were briefed on the proposals in the Consultative Steering Group."
UK Politics Contents
A-Z of Parliament