Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

Front Page



UK Politics







Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Low Graphics

Thursday, May 13, 1999 Published at 09:49 GMT 10:49 UK

UK Politics

Alan Clark: A clumsy war

Nato's air strikes "have worsened conditions on the ground"

Edited transcript of comments made by Alan Clark, MP for Kensington and Chelsea, in the House of Commons

I must start by saying that it is my opinion that this war is clumsy, wasteful and shambolic. I accept that the intentions of many of those who have signed up to it are honourable, but I can see neither clearly defined objectives nor any measurable progress in attaining them. Our prime minister appears to be making things up as he goes along.

[ image: Alan Clark: Argues no British interest exist in the Balkan region]
Alan Clark: Argues no British interest exist in the Balkan region
It is indisputable that the situation of all civilians living in Yugoslavia, be they Albanian Kosovars or the inhabitants of Belgrade, has greatly worsened since the Nato operation started.

I recognise that to state that leaves one open immediately to two charges. The first is that of wilfully condoning, or appeasing - as the secretary of state for international development said in answer to a question from me last week - the cruel and barbaric atrocities that have been perpetrated in parts of Yugoslavia. The second is that of wilfully, by implication, undermining the morale of our armed forces.

The first of those charges is, of course, absurd. General accusations that are neither justified nor applicable are no way to address the complexities, the centuries-old feuds and vendettas of Balkan tribesmen.

As for the second, it is certainly an uncomfortable charge to lay at the door of any Conservative member - not least a former minister at the Ministry of Defence - that he has undermined the morale and effectiveness of our fighting men.

Kosovo: Special Report
I should remind the House that, unlike some of the players in this drama, I have never been a member of CND. Nor am I a draft-dodger. When the second world war was still on, I enlisted on the earliest day that it was physically possible - on my 17th birthday.

Two of my sons, one of whom was decorated with the Gulf medal, have served in the army. That gives me a strong entitlement to say that British service men are not recruited to kill non-combatants. Were they ever to do so, it is no more than our electorate would expect for us in this place to protest.

Let me say that, although the camouflage of the Nato flag is used to divest and to spread responsibility for what has happened in recent days, I am entirely satisfied that the events are in no way attributable to the Royal Air Force.

The United States air force is another case altogether. Over many years, its record has been abominable, whether we are talking about Iranian air liners, British soldiers in personnel carriers, bridges, trains, factories or, apparently, refugee convoys in Yugoslavia. That air force is the worst instrument, the House might think, to let loose in a conflict where the distinction between combatant and non-combatant is often variable and elusive.

It will not be lost on the House that it is an order from the Pentagon that has prevented the somewhat muddled and inchoate Nato press office from showing the video of the attack on the refugee convoy. My heart sank when I heard that a contingent from the Number 10 press office was being sent to Brussels to help Nato to put a spin on things. One does not spin details of accident and bloodshed.

[ image: The Kosovo Liberation Army contains a
The Kosovo Liberation Army contains a "criminal element", Clark says
The House should consider the interaction of national and military complexities and susceptibilities. The Honourable Member for Linlithgow [Tam Dalyell] was howled down for reminding the House of the criminal element, terrorist conduct and many undesirable aspects of the KLA, but that has been confirmed by many, including in a long article in The Wall Street Journal. Mr Jeremy Bowen, the BBC correspondent, was stopped by members of the KLA and all his money and equipment was stolen.

The KLA are exactly the sort of people British service men should never fight alongside. It has been suggested that we should undertake to arm the KLA. Labour Members may recall the Contras, the Sandinistas and other groups who were armed by the CIA. That is the company that we will be in if we arm the KLA.

Advanced options | Search tips

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©

UK Politics Contents

A-Z of Parliament
Talking Politics
Vote 2001

Relevant Stories

13 May 99 | UK Politics
Diane Abbott: Nato has no Plan B

13 May 99 | UK Politics
Alice Mahon: Public opinion turning

13 May 99 | UK Politics
Martin Bell: Echoing disquiet

Internet Links


Kosovo Crisis Centre


UNHCR: Kosovo news

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

In this section

Livingstone hits back

Catholic monarchy ban 'to continue'

Hamilton 'would sell mother'

Straw on trial over jury reform

Blairs' surprise over baby

Conceived by a spin doctor?

Baby cynics question timing

Blair in new attack on Livingstone

Week in Westminster

Chris Smith answers your questions

Reid quits PR job

Children take over the Assembly

Two sword lengths

Industry misses new trains target