BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in:  UK Politics
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Sunday, 24 February, 2002, 11:02 GMT
Byers faces new spin row
Martin Sixsmith and Stephen Byers have different stories to tell in the spin row
Martin Sixsmith and Stephen Byers differ in their version of events
The "spin row" controversy at the Department of Transport has resurfaced with claims that the announcement of one senior civil servant's resignation was false.

Stephen Byers had backed the resignations of his department's press chief Martin Sixsmith and transport special adviser Jo Moore, saying they had "done the right thing" by quitting.

I wasn't sacked, I didn't resign, I haven't offered my resignation

Martin Sixsmith

Mr Sixsmith has now said he did not resign over the row about "burying" bad news, and insists he remains in the post.

But the government has again insisted that both he and Ms Moore had quit.

The latest twist in the saga has led to renewed accusations that Transport Secretary Stephen Byers has manipulated the truth and should stand down.

Shadow transport secretary Theresa May told BBC1's Breakfast With Frost: "What we've seen here is somebody who is more interested in sticking by his special adviser and in manipulating the news than he was in the underlying facts and truth of the situation."


Mr Sixsmith said on Saturday night: "I wasn't sacked, I didn't resign, I haven't offered my resignation.

"So when [Stephen Byers] announced it, he was in the very least mistaken."

The department then said in a statement: "Martin Sixsmith agreed with the Permanent Secretary of DTLR (Sir Richard Mottram) to resign from his post as director of communications on 15 February.

"This was agreed on the basis that Jo Moore also resigned and the terms of his resignation were agreed with him.

Martin Sixsmith agreed... to resign from his post as director of communications on 15 February

Transport department statement
"Discussion on the terms of his resignation have been continuing on the basis that these were confidential between him and the department."

Mr Sixsmith later insisted: "I have still not been sacked, I have still not resigned. No terms have been agreed. I still consider that I am in the job of director of communications at the DTLR."

He said that on 15 February, Sir Richard had asked him to resign with Ms Moore. He said he would consider it, and went off to a hospital appointment.

'Complete cock-up'

But on the way back from the hospital, he heard on the radio that both he and Ms Moore had quit.

"I was somewhat alarmed by that. I asked to see Byers but he wouldn't see me," he said.

Later that day, he added, Sir Richard then told him he was sorry but there had been a "complete cock-up", and someone had leaked the news of two resignations.

Sir Richard reportedly said: "How do we get the department and the government out of this mess?"

A report in the Sunday Times says Mr Sixsmith kept a detailed dossier of every phone call and meeting he had during the row, which backs up his version of events.


I think it is quite clear he is incapable of running his department

Teresa May
The shadow transport secretary called on Mr Byers to quit in light of the new claims.

She told the BBC: "I think it is quite clear he is incapable of running his department.

"His department is in absolute chaos, there's no trust between ministers and civil servants, he compromised the impartiality of civil servants and I think it's clearly a resigning matter."

Scottish Secretary, Helen Liddel, told the same programme the row proved the communications side of that department was dysfunctional and needed sorting out.

The row began with a reported disagreement between Mr Sixsmith and Ms Moore over whether rail statistics should be published on the day of Princess Margaret's funeral.

There were reports that Mr Sixsmith rebuked Ms Moore, who infamously wanted to "bury" bad news on 11 September, for planning to release bad rail figures on that day.

The affair led to accusations that the ministry was "at war" with itself, with staff leaking against each other, and that the neutrality of the civil service was being undermined.

On 15 February it was reported that both had quit, and Mr Byers released a statement that they had done "the right thing".

The BBC's John Andrew
"The Conservatives think this time Mr Byers has gone too far"
UK Shadow Transport Secretary Theresa May
"It shows the incredible pressure civil servants have been put under by Stephen Byers"
Don Foster MP, Lib Dem, Transport
"Martin Sixsmith has been very badly treated"
See also:

16 Feb 02 | UK Politics
Pressure grows for spin doctor curbs
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK Politics stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK Politics stories