BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in:  UK Politics
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Monday, 29 October, 2001, 20:28 GMT
Asylum seekers to get ID cards
A Glasgow shopkeeper with vouchers used in his shop
A Glasgow shopkeeper with vouchers used in his shop
UK Home Secretary David Blunkett is to scrap the controversial voucher and dispersal systems as part of a "fundamental and radical reform" of the asylum and immigration system.

In a statement to the House of Commons, Mr Blunkett acknowledged the current system was too slow, vulnerable to fraud and unfair both on local people and on asylum seekers.

I do not intend to tinker with the existing system but to bring about radical and fundamental reform

David Blunkett
Instead a system of smart cards, carrying fingerprints and photographs, would be introduced to provide people arriving in the UK with identification.

Mr Blunkett said the whole way in which asylum applications were processed would be overhauled with unsuccessful applicants removed speedily from the country.

By the same token, those who applied successfully to stay would be speedily integrated.

He said up to 3,000 people would initially be offered places in accommodation centres.

There they would receive full board, access to legal advice and a small cash allowance.

Refusal to stay in the centres would result in a loss of benefits.

Mr Blunkett said: "I do not intend to tinker with the existing system but to bring about radical and fundamental reform of our asylum and immigration policy.

Interests of all

"I believe it will send a message to the rest of the world that the UK is not open to abuse but nor is it a fortress Britain.

"Implementation of my policies will take time, but in time they will work in the interests of us all."

The shake-up has already been welcomed by the Conservatives and the TGWU union - one of the fiercest critics of the voucher scheme, which it called demeaning.

The plans also include the introduction of American green card-style work permits.

It was Mr Blunkett's predecessor Jack Straw who introduced the voucher system for asylum seekers buying food, clothes and other essentials.

'Stigmatising' scheme

Critics, including a number of Labour MPs, were unhappy with practical aspects of the scheme and said it stigmatised those forced to use it.

Mr Blunkett hopes the plan to use induction and reporting centres should speed up asylum applications by focusing legal assistance and other support services in one location.

Michael Martin
Michael Martin...unusual step
The government decided on a review of the dispersal system following the death of a Turkish refugee in Glasgow, a knife attack on an asylum seeker in Hull and protests over detention conditions in Cardiff.

Unlike the existing secure camp at Oakington, Cambridgeshire, the centres were expected to be open.

Tory welcome

Conservative home affairs spokesman Oliver Letwin said the current "mess" was due in great part to Mr Straw.

But he went on to welcome many elements in the home secretary's announcement and said: "The whole country will hope your new proposals will establish a civilised humane and effective system."

Speaker Michael Martin took the unusual step of welcoming Mr Blunkett's statement.

He said the voucher system took away people's dignity.

Parliamentary rules forbid him from taking part in debates even though he is an MP.

His possibly unpredecented intervention follows the stabbing to death of a 22-year-old Turkish Kurd asylum seeker in his constituency during the summer.

'Ill-judged' policy

There are currently more than 40,000 asylum seekers awaiting rulings on their cases, which take an average of seven months to be completed.

The TGWU's Bill Morris said he would welcome the scrapping of both the voucher scheme and the dispersal system.

The Refugee Council's Nick Hardwick also welcomed the news that the voucher system would go.

But an unnamed one asylum seeker at the Sangatte refugee centre in France said: "We don't want live in a camp, we want to be free."

Another said: "It is good for the English government but for asylum people not good, for refugees not good. It is very, very bad."

Sangatte became associated earlier in the year with bids by asylum seekers to gain access to the UK.

The BBC's Margaret Gilmore
"The scale of the problem is abundantly clear"
The BBC's Andrew Marr
"This is really big news in terms of government policy"
See also:

26 Oct 01 | UK Politics
Immigrants 'to take citizen classes'
29 Oct 01 | Scotland
Concern over asylum seeker plans
29 Oct 01 | UK Politics
Asylum shake-up at a glance
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK Politics stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK Politics stories