BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: UK Politics
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Monday, 22 October, 2001, 13:29 GMT 14:29 UK
No 10: War dissenters free to speak
An anti-war rally in London
There have been numerous anti-war rallies
Downing Street has moved to quash suggestions that the government was suppressing dissent over military action in Afghanistan.

A spokesman for Prime Minister Tony Blair insisted people were free to hold their opinions, saying: "It's a democracy".

We have to remember why we have embarked on this action

Downing Street spokesman
At the weekend Labour MP Paul Marsden took the unusual step of putting on the record a private conversation with Chief Whip Hilary Armstrong, whom he said had told him that war was not a matter of conscience.

He also said Ms Armstrong had compared Labour opponents of the bombing campaign with people who tried to appease Hitler in the 1930s.

'Remember terror images'

A spokesman for Prime Minister Tony Blair said: "We have to remember why we have embarked on this action - it's all too easy to forget over time what happened on 11 September and the image of the planes flying into the towers."

With the Whips' office insisting nobody had been restricted in what they said in Parliament on the military campaign, Jack Straw attacked Mr Marsden's decision to publish a version of what had been a confidential conversation.

The foreign secretary said it was he who had first compared those opposed to military action to people who supported the policy of appeasement in the 1930s.
Labour anti-bombing MPs
Paul Marsden
Alan Simpson
Robert Marshall-Andrews
Alice Mahon
Tam Dalyell
Lynne Jones
Kelvin Hopkins
Julie Morgan
Jeremy Corbyn
Neil Gerrard
Harold Best
Ronnie Campbell
John McDonnell
George Galloway

He said: "Of course I understand why people want to avoid that choice."

On Monday Mr Marsden again spoke out on the conflict, saying that US and UK military action was killing hundreds.

He said that opposition to the strikes within Parliament could not be assessed without a vote on the issue.

He claimed there were other Labour MPs who shared his views but who felt unable to express them.

But in an unprecedented move, Labour whip Anne McGuire went on record to suggest the media was stirring up the issue.

"I think there is a myth around that somehow the Whips' Office is this sort of dragon entity that goes round putting thumb screws on people," she told BBC Radio 4's World At One programme.

There is a myth around that somehow the Whips' Office is this sort of dragon entity that goes round putting thumb screws on people

Anne McGuire
Labour whip
Ms McGuire said Mr Marsden's "so-called transcript" was only his interpretation of the meeting.

"The chief whip is entitled and is actually charged with speaking to individual members of Parliament where they have concerns over issues of policy," she continued.

"She would have been failing in her duty if she had not asked if Paul wanted to speak to her."

Ms McGuire added: "There has been absolutely no way in which anyone has been restricted in what they have been able to say in the three recalls of Parliament.

"Nobody has said that Tam Dalyell, George Galloway or Paul Marsden can't voice their opinion."

Mr Marsden is one of 14 Labour MPs who have signed a parliamentary motion calling for a halt to the military strikes.

'Hardened views'

Last week Mr Marsden claimed his critical views of coalition bombing in Afghanistan had only been hardened by party whips' attempts to pressure him into toning down his comments.

The MP has repeatedly called for a Commons vote on the issue.

At a meeting last Tuesday, Ms Armstrong urged him to follow the party line and to clear any future motions or media appearances with her, according to Mr Marsden.

Explaining that he had refused to comply with Ms Armstrong's demand, Mr Marsden said: "My views against the bombing have only hardened after this meeting."

He continued: "I made it clear that I would not be backing down on my views that Parliament should be given a vote in this war."

The BBC's John Pienaar
"This debate still needs sensitive handling"
Paul Marsden, Labour backbencher
"I will not shut up about the war"
Geoff Hoon, Defence Secretary
"Paul Marsden is clearly entitled to his point of view"

Key stories


War view



See also:

22 Oct 01 | UK Politics
The world's oldest political profession
22 Oct 01 | UK Politics
Young pretender to awkward squad
22 Oct 01 | UK Politics
Low-key rise to top table
13 Oct 01 | UK
Protesting for peace
16 Oct 01 | UK Politics
Labour MPs call for bombing halt
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK Politics stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK Politics stories