BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: UK Politics
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Monday, 24 September, 2001, 10:28 GMT 11:28 UK
ID cards opposition grows
There are growing warnings against any rushed introduction of compulsory ID cards in the UK.

Liberal Democrat leader Charles Kennedy said history showed that rushed law changes supported by all UK parties had tended to be bad legislation.

He added that ID cards had failed to stop terrorism in other countries - such as France, Spain and Italy - where they were already in place.

Nobody need talk about recalling Parliament in this week or in the next two weeks to pass legislation

David Blunkett

The UK government is considering making identity cards compulsory as part of a crackdown on terrorism.

Home Secretary David Blunkett says he will not be rushed into making a "snap announcement" on cards or any other anti-terror measures.

He said: "I'm giving it a fairly high priority in terms of the discussions and the consideration behind the scenes.

"There are much broader issues about entitlement and citizenship and not merely security in terms of some form of identity card which we are looking at very seriously indeed."

He also maintained that improvements in electronic thumb or fingerprint technology or even "iris-prints" meant the threat of forgery would not make the system redundant.

'Rushed legislation'

But Lib Dem leader Charles Kennedy said: "Rushed legislation, particularly if it's got all party agreement, history teaches, is usually bad legislation."

David Blunkett
David Blunkett spoke of the need to protect civil liberties
Mr Blunkett maintained there was no need to recall Parliament in the next fortnight to debate new laws as they would take time to draft.

"Whatever we do will take time to put through Parliament even with emergency measures."

He said drafting and discussion would take time as was appropriate in a democracy.

But the home secretary admitted the "balance" between the Human Rights Act and anti-terror provisions may need to change.

Fighting terrorism

He said: "There will be tensions between the ECHR [European Court of Human Rights] and the Human Rights Act and the necessary protection that we seek.

"It is possible that we will have to change the balance."

The Conservatives have said they will support whatever steps are needed to fight terrorism.

Shadow foreign secretary Michael Ancram said the country always had to be careful about curtailing freedoms.

But he said the party would look at any proposal for identity cards or any other measure to fight terrorism.

Author and terrorism expert Michael Yardley said: "It is unfortunate that there are some people who will use the insecurity that is apparent at present to introduce draconian security measures for which there has long been support in certain quarters - but for which there has been public resistance."

Liberal Democrat foreign affairs spokesman Menzies Campbell, on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, questioned whether identity cards would be effective.

"Supposing you and I and everyone else in the United Kingdom had had compulsory identification cards on September 10 - are we both satisfied that there would have been no atrocities of the kind that took place in Washington and New York?

"If, however, a case could be made for identification cards which demonstrates that they will make a substantial contribution towards seeking out and preventing the sort of terrorist activity which took place in the United States here in the United Kingdom, then I will most certainly consider that case on its merits."

The BBC's Christine Stewart
"Increased security is highly visible on the streets"
Simon Hughes, LibDem Home Affairs Spokesman
"It's been on the agenda for years"
Mark Littlewood of Liberty and Gerald Howarth MP
discuss whether ID cards would help combat terrorism

Key stories


War view



See also:

21 Sep 01 | Americas
A warm New York welcome
20 Sep 01 | Europe
EU gears up to fight terrorism
23 Sep 01 | UK Politics
MPs urge parliament recall
23 Sep 01 | UK Politics
Labour 'unease' at retaliation plans
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK Politics stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK Politics stories