BBC News


Page last updated at 09:36 GMT, Monday, 22 September 2008 10:36 UK

Can forgetful people now relax?

Scan of the human brain

By Susan Blackmore
Presenter, Remember Remember

Names, phone numbers, directions - it can be a struggle to remember. Digital technology could soon make forgetfulness a thing of the past, but do we really want that?

It's a lively party. You see someone you know, you rush up to say hello and you can't remember their name. It's a common social faux pas, but help could soon be at hand.

Just as glasses and hearing aids are now commonplace, scientists are working on day-to-day digital devices to help us remember, with some taking inspiration from ancient times.

Remember Remember was on BBC Radio 3 on 21 September at 2130 BST
Catch up with the BBC iPlayer

"The nomenclator was in Roman times the person who went round telling the senator who they were meeting," says Wendy Hall, a professor of computer science at Southampton University.

"We think that quite soon we'll be able to develop a technology, like some combination of hearing aid and glasses, that will actually enable you to remember.

"We really think within the next five to 10 years you'll be able to be helped by memory aids."

Most of us already outsource our memories to electronic devices. Our mobiles remember phone numbers for us, and satnavs and GPS systems do the same for directions.


Engineer Lyndsay Williams decided to try and take things further when she started to regularly find a forgetful family member's missing mobile phone in the washing machine.

The Sensecam takes pictures every 30 seconds

At the time she was working for Microsoft Research in Cambridge, where she developed the SenseCam - a small digital camera to be worn around the neck. It takes pictures every 30 seconds, or when it detects a change in light or heat. At the end of the day you can review all the pictures - perhaps 2,000 shots - in a few minutes.

While reviewing the photos taken after a short walk around a science park in Cambridge, I remembered everything I'd thought about during the stroll - thoughts I might have forgotten if I'd never checked back.

Microsoft isn't planning to market the SenseCam, but researchers say it can provide real help for people who suffer from Alzheimer's or severe memory loss.

For many their most precious memories are of their children growing up, but one couple is taking this to extremes.

Speech scientist Deb Roy, of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and his wife are recording all the speech uttered in their home during the first three years of their son's life. High-quality microphones and video cameras are installed in the ceiling of every room.

"We have a total of somewhere in the order of 200,000 hours of audio and video," Professor Roy says.

The aim is study exactly what a child hears as he learns to speak. Along the way this "ultimate home video system" has provided some interesting surprises.

He recently looked up some video of his son's first steps, an occasion he thinks he can vividly recall.

"It was in the morning, it was in the hallway, I was with my wife and it was a special moment."

But when he looked at the video he found it had actually happened in the evening. What's more, his wife was away and he had shouted out to his mother instead.

"That memory error didn't impress my wife nor my mother," he says.

Total recall

The lure of all these burgeoning memory aids is that they might free up our minds to do other things, or help us relax because we know we have our precious memories stored.

Would you be stuck if it broke?

But is being able to remember more always a good thing? Professor Jim McGaugh, of the University of California at Irvine, has his doubts.

He has studied three rare people with what he calls "hyperthymestic syndrome" - an uncanny ability to remember what happened on every day of their adult life. Among them is Jill Price.

"If I ask her what happened on 12 May, 1993, she'll say first of all the day of the week and then she'll say something of what she did that day. If there was a significant public event - a plane crash, a train crash, a war - she'd be able to give the details."

But none of these people has benefited greatly from their ability. Indeed, rather the reverse in Ms Price's case.

"If she thinks of the date today, then she'll think of the date last year and the year before and the year before," he says. "Then she'll come across a day in which something terrible happened and that's very disturbing to her."

Like some of these digital devices, Jill's amazing memory means she is deficient in an underrated human skill - forgetting.

Below is a selection of your comments.

The last throwaway line in this article is actually a very important point - the ability to forget is what shields us from bad memories and allows us to get on with life.
John Smith, Leeds

I spent the first seven years of my son's life recording everything: his first time on a swing, first time in the snow, taking a bath in the sink, etc. One day, we realized that the video tape had aged. It had deteriorated. At first we lost colour, then audio. Now there is nothing. I'm a bit bitter about it. My point is: technology is not always "forever". In some ways technology can fail just like the human brain can.
Timothy Sinnott, Stamford, CT, USA

I write lists to remember what I need to take/buy... but then forget to read or take the list.
Anne, Essex

I used to be good at doing maths in my head, but then I got a calculator and now can't work anything out without one. I also used to be good at remembering all my appointments, but then I got a PDA and now I don't even know what I'm doing next. My hair used to dry on it's own, but then I got a hair drier and now it won't dry without one.
Judy Cabbages, Peebles, Scotland

The reason I keep a diary is to peg the days events into place, I would find such a device useful. At 0100 as I sit down to write up the day's events, my thoughts of 0755 yesterday can be a bit vague. Why keep a diary? Well it means I have a past as well as a future, it is enlightening to see how one's thought change over the years. Reading past diaries makes me realise there is wisdom in age (or at least in my case) as I cringe at the way I was thinking years before.
Roger, OX9

While not quite as extreme as Jill Price, I have a very good memory... it's like replaying a film clip. It's sometimes hard to remember that other people don't remember things so easily.
Megan, Cheshire, UK

I did psychology at uni and it is certainly true that: 1) the body is less stressed when it knows there is a back-up for what's important to remember - like if you write a list of what you need to do the next day before you go to bed; 2) forgetting serves an important purpose too.
Daryl, Belfast

I was thinking of fitting CCTV in my house so I can always find my car keys. It's a daily event trying to locate them. It's almost like I hide them from myself.
Kevin Yeandel, Macclesfield


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific