What if humans cast aside processed foods and saturated fats in favour of the sort of diet our ape-like ancestors once ate? Nine volunteers gave it a go... and were glad they did so.
By Claire Heald
BBC News Magazine
Being locked in the zoo and offered bananas to eat is the kind of extreme diet scenario to wake some of us screaming in the night. But that was how a group of volunteers opted to try to cut their blood pressure and cholesterol levels.
They set up home in a tented enclosure at Paignton Zoo, Devon, next to the ape house, in an experiment filmed for TV. The idea, says Jill Fullerton-Smith, who helped organise the trial, was that modern diets, often dominated by processed foods and saturated fats, cause costly health problems.
EVO DIET: WHAT THEY ATE
5kgs or 2,300 calories of fruit, vegetables, nuts and honey
On a 3-day rota, typically:
Broccoli, carrots, radishes
Cabbage, tomatoes, watercress
Strawberries, apricots, bananas
Mangoes, melons, figs, plums
For example, nearly half Britain's 117,000 annual deaths from coronary heart disease are linked to high cholesterol, according to the British Heart Foundation. And while the government urges everyone to eat five portions of fruit and veg a day, obesity is still rising.
So could an experiment on ordinary people's lives deliver the healthy eating message?
Nine volunteers, aged 36 to 49, took on the 12-day Evo Diet, consuming up to five kilos of raw fruit and veg a day.
The regime was devised by nutritionist and registered dietician Lynne Garton and King's College Hospital. It was based on research showing such a diet could have health benefits for cholesterol levels and blood pressure, because it is made up of the types of foods our bodies evolved to eat over thousands of years.
Ms Garton looked for inspiration to the plant-based diet of our closest relatives, the apes, and devised a three-day rotating menu of fruit, vegetables, nuts and honey. The prescribed menu was:
• safe to eat raw;
• met adult human daily nutritional requirements; and
• provided 2,300 calories - between the 2,000 recommended for women and 2,500 for men,
Volunteers could also drink water. In the second week, standard portions of cooked oily fish were introduced - a nod to a more hunter-gatherer lifestyle.
Among the volunteers was Jon Thornton, 36, a driving instructor from Sheffield, who had never eaten vegetables, from childhood upwards.
Weighing in at almost 19-stone, his typical diet read like the children's book, Mr Strong. Breakfast was four slices of toast; at 10am a bacon sausage and egg sarnie followed; fish and chips for tea and a Chinese take-away before bed.
That was before his wife signed up Mr Thornton for the experiment. Over 12 days he lost 5.7kg (12.5lbs), and reduced his cholesterol by 20%. His blood pressure also fell.
Despite nearly backing out at the start - the first day's food arrived in a cool-box, was raw and he was distinctly uncomfortable with the idea of broccoli - he was converted to eating vast portions of fresh fruit and veg.
"I didn't feel any loss of energy, I didn't feel ill at all," he says. "It's not a diet you'd recommend as a diet itself, but it worked to bring my cholesterol and blood pressure down."
Harmony in camp
With so much food bulk and plenty of calories the subjects did not go hungry - indeed most failed to finish their daily ration. And once they were over the withdrawal from caffeinated drinks and some foods, says Ms Garton, they enjoyed good energy levels and mood.
So the "moments of unhappiness and grumpiness" that the TV crew was primed to capture failed to happen. The proved to be a motivated group, although the one odorous side-effect from all that roughage couldn't be ignored.
Driving instructor Jon cut his cholesterol and his weight
Overall, the cholesterol levels dropped 23%, an amount usually achieved only through anti-cholesterol drugs statins.
The group's average blood pressure fell from a level of 140/83 - almost hypertensive - to 122/76. Though it was not intended to be a weight loss diet, they dropped 4.4kg (9.7lbs), on average.
The regime provided an education for all, and a permanent change for some.
"The main lesson that they took away was to eat more fruit and veg," says Ms Garton. They also cut salt intake from a group average of 12g a day, to 1g (against a guideline maximum of 6g) and reduced saturated fat - which makes cholesterol - from 13% to 5% of calories (recommended, 11%).
At the same time, they increased the soluble fibre which binds cholesterol in the gut, so that it is expelled, and increased the intake of plant sterols - which help to lower cholesterol.
For Jon, life has changed since he was "released" from the zoo. He has gained a little weight but now says he only eats when hungry and knows good food can help health and longevity. He can play football because his knees no longer hurt under the extra weight and he goes cycling.
He even managed to hold out at the most tempting time of year. "For the first time in 36 years this year I had vegetables with my Christmas dinner," he says. "Usually, I say no to them and have a few extra roast potatoes instead."
The Truth About Food is on BBC Two, Thursday, 11 January at 2100 GMT.
Add your comments on this story, using the form below.
Yes you can eat well on a plant only diet - it's called being vegan. And the food does not have to be dull.
It's amazing what can be achieved with a little will power. Slightly extreme, but we survived for millions of years in this way, and surely if everything comes full circle, the days of fast food could be numbered?
This is all just common sense really. I don't think it's possible for anyone in the twenty-first century to not know how to eat healthily. The information has not only been available to us but has been actively shouted at us for as long as I can remember. I lost forty pounds last year after giving up a lot of processed food and carbohydrates, and moving to simpler and often more pleasing meals, such as a bowl of fruit for my evening meal. I also got on my bicycle and started exercising every day after work. I am more fit now than ever before.
Mark L. Scott, Briton in the USA
Sounds great and you don't have to cook.
I notice there's no mention of the cost of this wondrous diet.
Drew McMutrie, Livingston, Scotland
I've always been a firm believer in this way of eating. I don't have a diet regime and sometimes I eat the most unhealthy, fattening, salt-laden things (e.g. a 10 piece family KFC bucket for 1) but for the vast majority of the time, I only eat when I'm hungry and I eat plenty of fruit and raw or partially cooked veg. I'm 25, very healthy, 6ft1 and just over 11 stone. Never tired, stressed or irregular. All diets are a sham, once people see past the need for the 3 meals a day at set times rubbish a lot of people will start to get healthier.
There is a significant variable in here that has not been accounted for: to what extent is the lower cholesterol and blood pressure the result of 12 days in a relaxed and laid back environment, rather than 12 days in the busy mess of work, life and everything else?
Matthew G, London
I think the problem with the 5-a-day campaign is that many people think they should eat 5 portions of fruit/veg in addition to all their existing junk. Perhaps it should be made clearer that they also need to reduce their intake of modern processed trash?
David, Cheshire, UK
If we need TV programmes to teach us to eat the diet our bodies evolved for then we really are all doomed.
Ian Westbrook, Folkestone, Kent
I don't think much of that diet as an 'ape diet'. Is that nutritionist aware that our closest relatives are omnivores who, in the case of Bonobos, if not all chimps, will kill and eat their own kind? More half-baked disinformation from the "eat healthy" brigade!
Mike Watkinson, London
Drew McMutrie asks about the cost of the diet. It always amazes me when people say they can't afford to eat healthy food - fruit and veg are really cheap! Whenever I'm on a health kick (like now) I feel very smug at the supermarket checkout with bags and bags of produce for only a tenner, whereas the person in front was buying chips, crisps, biscuits, ready meals etc and paying several times as much fir the privilege.
I'm almost certain that the ancestral environment in which we evolved did not provide us with tropical fruits such as mangoes alongside mild-climate vegetables like cabbage and broccoli. Nor did it allow us to eat summer fruits like strawberries in the same three days as autumnal produce like hazelnuts. By all means cut out the processed foods, but dressing it up as some faddy 'evo diet' is just more nutritional nonsense.
Bonobos do not eat each other; Mike Watkinson's comment is confusing Bonobos with common Chimpanzees, who have only been seen to kill and eat each other under extreme environmental stress.
Thomas Worthington, Bangor, NI
Yes it was a publicity stunt, but unlike other stunts this had several real points to make. And what better way than by taking advantage of the Big Brother mania that is sweeping the country.
Derek Taylor, Kent, England
The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published. Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide.