[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Friday, 27 October 2006, 12:58 GMT 13:58 UK
Heard the one about...
By Claire Heald
BBC News Magazine

David Blunkett and Tony Blair
Blunkett was concerned enough to 'tell Tony'
Urban myth or terror warning? How David Blunkett took a tale of a rumoured attack straight to the top.

It is a story that has dropped in to many an e-mail in-box or been passed on by word-of-mouth. And its distribution has picked up in these times of heightened security since the 11 September and 7 July attacks.

The characters in the story and its location vary, but the plot stays mostly the same. It runs as follows:

    "My friend's Aunt Sally was in a queue and this Middle Eastern-looking bloke in front of her dropped his wallet. When she gave it back to him, he told her to avoid central London on Saturday because something big might happen. Tell as many people as you can."

Most people sigh, and delete the e-mail.

David Blunkett's book
We've come through Remembrance Sunday safely. All the worry was for nothing, thank God
David Blunkett's diary
But when this same tale crossed David Blunkett's path in late 2001, he passed it straight to the top.

An entry in his newly-published diary reveals how he had spoken to an old school friend, who had heard the story involving the return of a wallet to an Arab man and a warning not to be in London on 11 November.

"I immediately registered the significance of this," Blunkett wrote at the time. "The 11th of November is Armistice Day, the one day in the year when all leading politicians from the three parties, the Queen, other members of the Royal family, and the leading personnel of the armed services are in the same place at the same time - a known time, in central London.

"I decided that I should at least tell Tony Blair as it was absolutely clear that nobody had fully thought through the significance.

"We agreed there was no way we could possibly cancel Armistice Day, but we were certainly going to have to take increased precautions."

Then later: "Sunday 11th of November: And we've come through Remembrance Sunday safely. All the worry was for nothing, thank God."

Long story

The basis for all that worry? An urban myth that's been doing the rounds for decades in one form or another. When the troubles in Northern Ireland were at their height, the tipster was an Irishman. The location has moved around the UK - to Birmingham, Coventry, Reading. Abroad it has centred on different US cities.

If it's really true, show me the carcass
Albert Jack
But it dates back at least as far as a myth surrounding the Hiroshima bombings, says Albert Jack, author of That's B*ll*cks: Urban Legends, Conspiracy Theories and Old Wives' Tales.

In that version Americans were apparently warned to get out of the city before the atomic bomb was dropped.

A similar but also false myth followed the Twin Towers attack, that Muslim workers had been warned to stay home, and was reported in New York on 12 September.

The terror warning tale is similar in nature to the "missing kidney" and "long-dead hitchhiker" urban myths, says Mr Jack.

The first involves a person who goes to a party with friends, only to wake up in a bath of ice minus their kidneys. The second a driver who gives a girl a lift home, only to discover when she disappears that she died years earlier in a car crash.

"All these e-mails are the modern-day version of medieval folklore," says Mr Jack.

"Many people tell stories like this to make themselves more popular. If you stand in the pub and tell stories, a lot of them will make you laugh, and so people think it makes them popular."

Urban myths may arise from a snippet or a fact, or from what conspiracy theorists might like to believe. The origin is hard to pin-point once they've started to spread and mutate. But it is when people in power hear and act on them that they gain credence.

How to guard against falling for one? Mr Jack says: "I always say, 'If it's really true, show me the carcass'. These things are so often repeated, it's unimaginative to tell them, so show me the evidence."

Add your comments on this story, using the form below.

I heard this extract on Radio 4 and was astonished. I'm sure we can all be taken in by false stories, and that intelligence can be gathered from the most varied of sources. But for a Home Secretary to provide a security warning to the PM on a baseless story which a friend in Canada has recounted, is more than a little bizarre and possibly even reckless.

Surely Home Office officials, the security services, the PM or even a bloke down the pub could have let him know that he'd been had. If not then, certainly since.
Mike, Bromley

My favourite urban myth is the one about the rabbit. A woman looks out of her window to see her dog playing with next door's large white rabbit, dead. She takes the mud-covered animal inside and painstakingly restores it to a spotless condition.

She then places the rabbit back in its hutch. Satisfied that she has avoided a bitter confrontation with her neighbour and carries on as before - making sure her dog is locked inside the house.

After several hours she hears screaming coming from the garden next door, sees her neighbour standing in front of the hutch with her children and all are clearly distressed.

"What's wrong?" she asks. "The rabbit. It's dead!" is the reply. "She had a stroke and the vet put her to sleep. We buried her at the bottom of the garden yesterday!"

Of course, this didn't happen to me, but my friend swears it happened to the friend of his sister.
Allan, London.UK

Firstly, some myths are convincing. Secondly, had this been for real and he had not reacted, we wouldn't be taking the mickey. Sometimes this kind of a response is actually a good thing.
Dave, Bristol, UK

Urban myths often start as ways to warn about very general principles; for example the message in the "missing kidney after party with strangers" story is that bad things can happen when people are trusting of people they don't know.

However, they can also be ways to spread prejudice about a certain group, for example the urban myth about there being no people of certain groups present at certain terrorist attacks. Stories like that, that falsely hint that everyone of a particular group would know about something that was going to happen, needlessly spread hatred and mistrust.
Karl Chads, London, UK

Henry Porter wrote a book called Remembrance Day 6 years ago - the plot was an attack on the ceremony at the cenotaph. Especially after the various IRA atrocities on that day security would be at full alert anyway. Blunkett's warning would make no difference.
Peter, Nottingham

Your e-mail address
Town/city and country
Your comment

The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published. Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide.

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific