[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Tuesday, 18 January, 2005, 11:26 GMT
Rank and bile
By Jonathan Duffy
BBC News Magazine

(Picture posed by actor)
(Picture posed by actor)
Ex-lawyer Rodney Hylton-Potts won ITV's reality Vote For Me show with his "cabbie's manifesto", which includes policies to deport immigrants and castrate paedophiles. Would cab drivers - often cited as a good barometer of grass roots feeling - vote for him?

"We're capitalists, the smallest version of capitalists you can find," says taxi driver Alan Parker, as he weaves his vehicle through the central London traffic, heading north to Hampstead.

Alan, a cabbie for 35 years, is seeking to isolate what it is about the capital's black cab drivers that has earned them such a legendary reputation for being right wing loudmouths.

"We're self-employed," he says of his 24,000 colleagues, "each one of us a sole trader, a small businessman if you like."

In popular folklore, the cabbie's credo does not fit the profile of any one political party, but goes something like this: Europe - one big gravy train; criminals - lock 'em up and throw away the key; government - nannying overlords; business leaders - fat cats; single mothers - spongers; asylum seekers - foreign spongers, and so on and so forth.

Cabbies, both in London and elsewhere, are not alone in holding passionate views about how to put the world to rights. But unlike the rest of us, the ranting taxi driver is always blessed with a ready audience: the paying passenger.

Rodney Hylton-Potts
Cabbies' friend? Rodney Hylton-Potts
This potent combination of hard-edged rightist politics and a willingness to spout them at every opportunity seems to have inspired Rodney Hylton-Potts, winner of ITV's Vote for Me.

The show, which ran last week, was a Pop Idol-style contest in which viewers voted for budding MPs. Mr Hylton-Potts, a convicted fraudster and former solicitor, won on a manifesto that included halting immigration, the mandatory castration of paedophiles, the repeal of the Human Rights Act, the legalisation of all drugs and a massive prison-building scheme.

"I won because of what I call the cabbie vote," Mr Hylton-Potts said later, describing how his polices had been influenced by the cab drivers who drove him to and from the studios during the making of the show.

"I think cabbies are a very good guide. When I told them my views, every single one of them said 'Good on you, mate'."

It's not just Mr Hylton-Potts who lumps cabbies into a particular political class. The Guardian's Polly Toynbee once blamed Britain's "taxi driver tendency" for public scepticism about helping poor countries.


What about cabbies themselves? Will they be queuing up to vote for Mr Hylton-Potts come general election day?

Nothing could be further from the truth, but the myth persists - to tar us all with the same brush is highly insulting
Cabbie and Labour councillor Leon Reefe
Alan Parker, who mixes his cabbing work with teaching a course in London's history at City University, thinks not. Cab drivers represent a broad spectrum of backgrounds and political opinion he says, before admitting he falls into the politically conservative fold.

"I'm a Tory and have been all my life but at the last general election I voted UK Independence Party," he says.

Leon Reefe, a black cab driver for 25 years, and a Labour councillor, is offended by Mr Hylton-Potts' pigeonholing.

"It's total rubbish. Nothing could be further from the truth, but the myth persists because it's put about by the media. To tar us all with the same brush is highly insulting."

Mr Reefe says the stereotype of the white, working class, often Jewish, London cabbie is changing fast, as black people, Asians and those from the Far East join the ranks.

Nevertheless, he admits there is a definite tendency for his colleagues to lean to the right - something he blames on former Labour Home Secretary Merlyn Rees' repeated refusal to increase the cabbie's tariff during the 1970s.

Common touch?

So what is it about the cabbie's wisdom that seems to make such a big impression?

Rob Brydon
Minicab drivers too like to talk to their passengers
Taxi trade is often taken as an indication of wider economic factors - in short, the more free cabs there are cruising the streets of London, the less money we have in our pockets. It means the humble cabbie is at the sharp edge of any changes in the economy.

Malcolm Linskey, a former cabbie who has written histories of the London cab trade, says a combination of being one's own boss coupled with the rigours of The Knowledge - a tough entry exam that all London black cab drivers must pass - gives cabbies oodles of self-confidence.

"It makes them stroppy, free-thinkers, argumentative. They answer to nobody but themselves and that comes across in their conversation.

"Everyone wants to play them as fascists but it's a myth. It's just that those who are on the right will tend to speak their minds. The others keep their politics to themselves."

What do taxi drivers think of the "cabbie's manifesto"?

Alasdair Kay
[Hylton-Potts] was a bit extreme. He talked some sense but he went too far. Probably a lot of cabbies are on the right. We see all sides of life.
Halt to immigration? Yes
Castration of paedophiles?
Couldn't care less
Legalisation of all drugs? Don't know enough to comment
Repeal of Human Rights Act? It's PC gone too far
More prisons? No, offenders should do something to benefit the community
Alp Sezer
Cab drivers are maligned as xenophobes. It doesn't go for all of us. We might have our finger on the pulse, but that doesn't mean we're extreme.
Halt immigration? No
Castrate paedophiles? No
Legalise drugs? That's rubbish
Repeal Human Rights Act? Rubbish
More prisons? Don't know

John Horn
I'm a Tory. You talk to most people in a cab - they all think the same, as do all people who live in the real world. We're paying for scumbags.
Halt immigration? Yes
Castrate paedophiles? Yes
Legalise drugs? No
Repeal Human Rights Act? Yes
More prisons? Yes
Roger McDonald
He's made some good points there, but he doesn't speak for me. There's an element of taxi drivers who are to the right of Genghis Khan.
Halt immigration? No, but asylum seekers who break the law should be deported
Castrate paedophiles? No, that's a bit Draconian
More prisons? Yes
Legalise drugs? No
Repeal Human Rights Act? Possibly, but it would risk our membership of the EU

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific