[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 22 June 2006, 17:10 GMT 18:10 UK
Warning over football club claim
Michael Appleton
Michael Appleton had to retire at the age of 27
A compensation case brought by West Bromwich Albion football club against a surgeon could result in many similar cases, the appeal court has been told.

The club is claiming 1m in compensation against knee specialist Medhet Mohammed El-Safty.

They claim his advice to operate on a knee injury to midfielder Michael Appleton was unnecessary.

Lawyers for the surgeon told judges the case could result in an avalanche of cases brought by clubs against doctors.

West Brom began the claim over treatment to the midfielder who suffered a cruciate knee ligament injury in a training-ground accident in 2001.

Contractual obligation

The 750,000 signing was referred to the specialist who advised reconstruction surgery.

But the former Manchester United trainee never recovered and was forced to quit the game two years later aged 27.

West Brom claim the operation should never have gone ahead and if that had been the case the player would still be on the pitch.

The case centres on whether there was a contractual obligation between the specialist and the club.

Stephen Miller, acting for the specialist, said that, if West Brom won the case, the floodgates would be opened for a large number of potentially very high value claims against doctors not by their patients, but by their patients' employers.

A judge at the High Court last year rejected the claim ruling the surgeon had no contractual duty to the club.

Conservative treatment

At the Appeal Court on Thursday Mr Miller said: "It has been admitted that it was negligent to have advised surgery at the outset and that conservative measures should have been tried first.

"Had they been, they would probably have been successful."

But he added the claim still failed without proof that Mr El-Safty owed the club a "duty of care" recognised by the law of negligence.

The appeal judges in the case are expected to reserve their decision on the club's appeal until a later date.

West Brom sue 'negligent' surgeon
21 Jun 06 |  West Midlands
Ex-West Brom star to sue surgeon
21 Jun 05 |  West Bromwich Albion


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific