[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Monday, 13 August 2007, 15:28 GMT 16:28 UK
Doctor criticises boob job prize
The winner wants to enhance her size from an A cup to a double D cup
Surgeons have hit out at a Merseyside radio station for offering breast augmentation as a competition prize.

A total of 40 women entered Juice FM's phone-in contest to win the enhancement operation valued at about £4,000.

However, the British Association of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons has condemned the competition saying it was "dangerous and highly unethical".

A station spokeswoman said finalists had been psychologically tested to ensure suitability for surgery.

'Always unhappy'

Entrants had to send a photo of themselves into the station with an explanation of why they wanted the operation and listeners then voted on who should get the surgery.

Winner, 27-year-old Nadine Pude from Rockferry, Wirral, is planning to get her bust boosted from an A-cup to a double D at the end of this month.

She defended the competition saying: "I've always been unhappy with what nature gave me and I never thought I would be able pay for a boob job.

"I'm happy with my height, my waist, and my weight. But I always thought I was lacking a 'bit up top'.

"My fiancé, Paul, was brilliant. He always said that if it made me happy, I should get a good job and save for a boob job."

However, Adam Searle, former president of the the British Association of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons, said: "The giving of a surgical procedure as a prize is an unbelievable, dangerous and highly unethical practice.

The offer of a cosmetic surgery procedure as a prize is an awful manifestation of the trivialisation of medical care in general, and aesthetic surgery in particular
Adam Searle, plastic surgeon

"The decision to perform any surgical procedure must be based on common sense, case selection, good surgical decision making and patient safety.

"The offer of a cosmetic surgery procedure as a prize is an awful manifestation of the trivialisation of medical care in general, and aesthetic surgery in particular.

"Any patients making irreversible decisions in circumstances of hype, excitement and emotion are putting themselves at very great risk.

"Any normal patient-doctor relationship is completely abandoned in any such framework of medical care. This is a practice I unreservedly and utterly condemn."

This is not the first time the station has offered surgical procedures as prizes - a few years ago they ran a competition where a woman won a nose job.

'Psychological evaluation'

Jo Heuston, who is sponsorship and promotions manager of Juice FM, said: "We take very seriously the interests of our listeners and would never seek to act irresponsibly towards them.

"A lot of women seeking surgical enhancement procedures have low self esteem and are desperate to have their perceived problems rectified.

"As a result they either have to save up for years or go into debt to enable themselves to get it carried out.

"All we were doing was offering the chance of the procedure without having to pay for it and as a precaution we sent the five finalists to the clinic for a psychological evaluation to make sure they were all suitable.

"If they hadn't, they would have been withdrawn from the competition."



The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific