Page last updated at 18:05 GMT, Friday, 15 August 2008 19:05 UK

Fine for 90p Oyster error quashed

Tom Usher
Mr Usher said he was unaware of his error as it was a new card

A passenger fined 90 for failing to pay a 90p bus fare, despite having enough money on his Oyster card, has won an appeal.

Tom Usher, 37, from Harlesden, north-west London, was fined and ordered to pay 100 court costs for not validating his card properly on a bendy bus.

But Kingston Crown Court ruled that he had a "reasonable excuse" as he was unaware his fare had not been deducted.

Mr Usher was "overjoyed", but said "it shouldn't have come to this".

He had 1.60 on his Oyster card when challenged by an inspector on a bendy bus in December last year.

No warning

Mr Usher said he was unaware of his error as it was a new card, but Transport for London (TfL) successfully prosecuted him in Wimbledon Magistrates Court.

His sentence was quashed on Friday when the court noted that bus passengers were not warned to check for a green light and a beep when touching their cards onto the reader.

Outside court Mr Usher said: "If something's wrong you have got to complain about it. If everyone starts complaining then maybe things will change."

A TfL spokesman said it was "disappointed" but accepted the decision.

"This case did not call into question our prosecutions policy or the need to prosecute fare evasion on London's buses, which costs taxpayers more than 30m a year," he added.

TfL estimated that each prosecution for fare evasion cost about 270, but it would not reveal how much it cost to prosecute Mr Usher.

Oyster 100m deal will end early
08 Aug 08 |  London
Oyster card hack to be published
21 Jul 08 |  Technology

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific