[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Tuesday, 25 November, 2003, 17:46 GMT
Doctors urge public smoking ban
Smoky bar
Doctors say passive smoking kills 1,000 adults a year
The Royal College of Physicians and 17 other medical colleges have called for a ban on smoking in public places.

In a letter to The Times, they warned there was now compelling evidence about the dangers of passive smoking.

They argued the system of voluntary self-regulation in bars and restaurants had failed, and called for legislation.

However, Health Minister Melanie Johnson backed the current system and said the government had no plans to introduce a ban.

The letter reflects international concern about the harmful effects of passive smoking, which doctors say kills 1,000 adults a year.

Ireland and Norway are on course to ban smoking in public places in the New Year.

Doctors' leaders says Britain's voluntary route, where bars and restaurants are encouraged to introduce no-smoking policies, is simply not enough.

They argue that passive smoking not only causes 1,000 deaths in adults each year, but is also responsible for asthma, lung infections and ear problems in children.

Smoke-free places are the ideal, but the evidence is that public opinion remains divided
Health Minister Melanie Johnson

Professor Carol Black of the Royal College of Physicians told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that evidence from the World Health Organisation, the UK Committee on Carcinogenicity and the government's own Committee on Science and Health all showed the need to introduce a public smoking ban.

"In 1998, the government said there was no doubt smoking kills and suggested progress could be achieved by working with [the tobacco] industry rather than to enforce a public ban. That progress has not been fast," she said.

Professor Black said only 36 pubs in the country had enforced their own smoking bans.

She added voluntary bans had not worked well, but an enforced public smoking ban could save about 160,000 lives per year.

Government response

Health Minister Melanie Johnson agreed the rate of progress over voluntary bans had not been good, but denied there was a need for a public ban.

"Smoke-free places are the ideal, but the evidence is that public opinion remains divided," she said.

"There is also cost and a difficulty involved in enforcing a no smoking ban."

She added there was a lot of room for the hospitality industry to enforce their own smoking bans, adding they had so far been slow to respond to demand."

The British people will get used to it
Ray, USA/ UK

Meanwhile, the Mayor of London is consulting on what Londoners think about where people should be able to smoke, and other cities such as Sheffield, Birmingham and Brighton are considering bringing in more restrictions.

In the summer, restaurant chain Pizza Hut claimed to be the UK's first nationwide restaurant chain to introduce a total smoking ban.

Deborah Arnott, director of the anti-smoking charity ASH, said: "Legislation to end employees' involuntary exposure to secondhand smoke at work is long overdue.

"Children also need protection when they are taken out to restaurants and other public places where smoking is still permitted.

"If the government has rejected calls for a new law, then it must spell out what exactly it does intend to do about the problem.

"To rely on 'voluntary action' without clear timetable targets and government support would be to fail those whose health is threatened by secondhand smoke and to abandon a vital weapon in the armoury of tobacco control."

A spokesman for the British Lung Foundation said: "More than 8 million people have a lung condition in the UK and all of them are severely aggravated by exposure to second hand smoke.

"People should have the right to be able to work without being exposed to dangers to their health."

The BBC's Vicki Young
"Doctors say passive smoking kills about three adults a day"

Q&A: Passive smoking
25 Nov 03  |  Medical notes
Charity backs anti-smoking bill
08 Nov 03  |  Scotland
Debate on smoking ban
28 Oct 03  |  London
Norway gets tough on smoking
24 Oct 03  |  Health
EU public smoking ban considered
19 Sep 03  |  Health
Warning over second-hand smoke
02 Sep 03  |  Health


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific