[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Friday, 27 June, 2003, 11:07 GMT 12:07 UK
Police cleared in supergrass case
Old Bailey
The chief prosecution witness was too ill to attend the Old Bailey
Four detectives accused of being part of a Flying Squad ring which siphoned off thousands of pounds in stolen cash, were acquitted at the Old Bailey on Friday.

Their prosecution had followed Britain's biggest ever investigation into police corruption.

The officers were cleared after another former policeman who turned "supergrass" failed to give evidence against them.

Detective Constable Kevin Garner had already blown the whistle on other former colleagues who had worked at Rigg Approach in Walthamstow, north east London.

But Jonathan Laidlaw, who led the prosecution, said Mr Garner was "in no fit state" to come to court because of the stress of six years of being a "supergrass".

Corrupt activities

The former officers - Detective Sergeant Eamonn Harris, 47, Detective Sergeant Michael Carroll, 47, Detective Constable David Thompson, 38, and Detective Constable Ian Saunders, 46, - were alleged to have taken 35,000 after catching a gang which had stolen more than 1m.

Their legal representatives said they had always protested, and continued to protest, their innocence.

Mr Garner had helped jail other fellow officers in recent years.

It is clear the pressures over the last six years have taken their toll. In his words, Mr Garner cannot cope any longer
Jonathan Laidlaw
He was jailed himself for six years after admitting a variety of offences between 1991 and 1996.

He then provided information to the police about alleged corrupt activities by former colleagues.

After the prosecution said there was no realistic chance of Mr Garner being fit to give evidence, Judge Gregory Stone entered verdicts of not guilty to charges of conspiracy to steal, handling stolen goods and perverting justice against the four defendants.

The men shook hands in the dock after being formally cleared.

Mr Laidlaw said the decision not to proceed with the prosecution had been taken "at the highest level of the Crown Prosecution Service and the Metropolitan Police".

'Supergrass witness'

Asked by the judge if the option of bringing Mr Garner to court had been considered, Mr Laidlaw said: "He is in no fit state.

"It would do further damage to someone already in an unfit state."

Some five-and-a-half years had elapsed since the four defendants were charged.

Mr Laidlaw said that during the May trial, it had emerged that Mr Garner was suffering from severe psychological and psychiatric difficulties.

"It is clear the pressures over the last six years have taken their toll."

The court was told Mr Garner had been ostracised as an informer, segregated in prison and was now in the Witness Protection Scheme with a new identity.

"He is finding it difficult to integrate himself," said Mr Laidlaw. "In his words, he cannot cope any longer.

"He falls into the category of a supergrass witness."

Two officers reinstated

Mr Laidlaw said there was little chance of a realistic prospect of conviction without Mr Garner's evidence.

All four men had been suspended from the police force on full pay.

Harris, who was jailed for seven years during a previous trial, was automatically dismissed on conviction and is still serving his sentence.

A Met Police spokesman said Mr Thompson and Mr Saunders would be reinstated although no decisions had been taken as to where they would serve.

Mr Carroll would remain suspended pending the decision of a disciplinary panel.

Force sets up anti-corruption team
06 Jun 03  |  West Midlands
Police corruption hotline launched
04 Mar 03  |  Northern Ireland
Met reveals corruption figures
28 Aug 02  |  England
Officers admit corruption charges
14 Oct 98  |  UK News

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific