Shops plan faces heritage critics

The developers already own most of the current site

The redevelopment of a Derbyshire shopping centre has been criticised by English Heritage.

A supermarket, four shops, a six-storey hotel and multi-storey car park are planned for Spring Gardens in Buxton.

But the heritage body said the plans were "not up to scratch" for a town with such existing character.

The developers have not responded to the comments. High Peak Borough Council will make a decision on the scheme at the end of the month.

The project has been proposed by Zurich Assurance, which already owns the bulk of the existing shopping centre, and Sainsbury's Supermarkets Ltd.

Consultation process

The architects have previously said that they would, wherever possible, use local materials and echo locally distinctive structures.

But Anthony Streeten from English Heritage insisted it was not opposed to new development but wanted it to fit with the town's character.

"We just don't think the elevations, particularly those facing that fantastic building, the crescent, are up to scratch for a town of the importance or the character of Buxton.

"We have to get it right because the building will be with us for many generations to come and I think the councillors have a huge responsibility."

The council said it was accepting all comments on the scheme as part of a consultation process until 23 November.

Its planning committee will meet on 30 November.