[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 2 September, 2004, 07:16 GMT 08:16 UK
Scanners hit by cash shortage
by Zoe Gough
BBC News Online

MRI scanner
MRIs can detect cancer, stroke and other health problems
Scanners paid for from charity cash are being left idle for hours on end - because some hospitals cannot afford to pay all the running costs.

About 40m of lottery cash has been spent in the past four years to buy more than 50 magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scanners for hospitals across the country.

And while many hospitals are able to use the equipment to treat patients every day, other units are struggling to even get the expensive equipment up and running.

Yet waiting times for the MRI scans, which can detect cancer, stroke and other health problems, have soared to up to 18 months in some places.

Indeed, the government has recently signed a five-year contract with private firm Alliance Medical Ltd to fill in the gaps.

Now, officials representing radiologists are meeting the Department of Health (DoH) to help increase the use of the permanent scanners.

MRIs installed since April 2000
113 MRIs (replacement and additional) installed to date since April 2000
55 were NOF funded
8 were Treasury/DoH funded
50 were funded/arranged by the NHS themselves
182 MRIs in place before April 2000.

Dr Paul Dubbins, from the Royal College of Radiologists, said: "We are in discussion with the DoH as to how we can utilise the spare capacity that may exist throughout the country."

Richard Evans, chief executive of the Society of Radiographers, said scanner running costs of about 250,000 a year were not taken into account by the charities or even the DoH when they spend money on the equipment.

He told BBC News Online: "Up and down the country there are very many places where there is much mothballing of MRI capacity or where it is used as back up, or not as well as staff would like to use it.

What is MRI?
A young boy in an MRI scanner
MRI scans have caused a revolution in medical diagnosis since the 1980s
They combine a powerful magnetic field, radio waves and a sophisticated computer to produce detailed pictures of the inside of the body.
It does not use x-rays, and there are no known dangers or side effects

"But an MRI scanner is pretty much an independent provision, there is quite a lot of political kudos in the huge investment in capital equipment.

"The problem lies with making sure it is properly resourced."

He said while consultant radiologists were in short supply the number of radiographer graduates was growing and they could take additional roles.

Cash for many scanners has come from the National Lottery's New Opportunities Fund, which gave money for sophisticated hospital equipment.

BBC News Online spoke to the 19 English hospital trusts awarded cash from the National Lottery's New Opportunities fund to buy scanners - many were still battling to find cash to run the machines as often as they would like.

One hospital with problems is The Royal Bolton, in Greater Manchester, which is treating patients with a mobile scanner while its own machine is often switched off.

It should run for 10 sessions a week but the trust can only afford six.

Ann Schenk, a hospital director, has said running costs had "to compete with other priorities" and a shortage of trained radiographers did not help.

She told BBC News Online: "It may well be the case that, for some developments, it is not always possible at the point of making the case for investment in equipment to have a precise source of revenue secured."

Hospital chiefs in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, also claim lottery officials did not check the hospital could afford to cover ongoing costs before handing over 800,000 for its machine.

The scanner at the Royal Shrewsbury Hospital could now be out of action for months because this year's budget cannot cope with the running costs.

Nick Webb, director of finance at Shropshire County Primary Care Trust, said: "As far as I can ascertain we never formally signed up to pay the revenue."

No more cash

But Vanessa Potter, a director at the Big Lottery Fund, said: "The sustainability of diagnostic equipment is a matter for determination by local partners and in particular for Primary Care Trusts (PCTs).

"The fund expects grant recipients to set out plans for sustainability, and we work closely with the DoH and other stakeholders to ensure this."

She said no further lottery cash was being provided by the MRI programme.

A spokeswoman for the Department of Health admitted the problem was not unique to Shrewsbury and Bolton but denied they were simply providing the machines for public acclaim.

"We are actively dealing with it by bringing new staff through and new equipment is now coming on line but the trusts are committed to funding it afterwards," she said.

Hi-tech scanner to be mothballed
06 Aug 04  |  Shropshire
Hospital defends scanner shutdown
02 Aug 04  |  Manchester


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific