[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 6 July 2006, 07:37 GMT 08:37 UK
Special needs education 'not fit'
Special needs class
Special needs schools have smaller classes and cost more per pupil
The system of education for pupils with special needs in England is "not fit for purpose", MPs have said.

The Commons education select committee is calling for stronger government guidelines for councils, to end a "postcode lottery" of provision.

It also wants ministers to clarify their policy on whether to include special needs children in mainstream schools or educate them separately.

The government said it had "done much" to improve the situation.


According to the committee, those with special educational needs (SEN) are being "sidelined".

It also claims the government's "inclusion" policy - teaching pupils in mainstream schools wherever possible - is causing confusion about whether this means closing special schools.

About 1.53 million children in England are judged to have SEN.

The number of special schools in the state and private sectors fell by 7% from 1,239 in 1997 to 1,148 last year.

Nadine Dorries
Without evidence it appears a policy of inclusion has developed on the basis that it benefits all children
Nadine Dorries MP

The committee says special schools, dealing with issues such as autism, behavioural and learning difficulties, are "invaluable" for many pupils.

It recommends more mainstream and special schools joining in federations to share ideas.

Committee chairman Barry Sheerman said: "Many of the problems identified in our report stem from the fact that SEN provision has not been given sufficient priority by successive governments."

He said standards varied widely.

"There's a high level of satisfaction out there - about 90% - with what parents get."

But it was "a tough, tough world" for the minority of families who had to fight to get a formal statement detailing their child's needs and how they should be met.

His committee's report says local authorities have an "inbuilt conflict of interest", in both having to assess whether a child needs special education - which is expensive - and having to provide it.


The committee argues that mainstream schools' need to do well in league tables means some are unwilling to accept special needs children, for fear of damaging average test results.

It says: "Regardless of the theory, in practice the evidence clearly demonstrates that SEN and the raising achievement agenda sit very uncomfortably together at present."

The needs of the child should come first and preference of the parents should be given very great weight
Lord Adonis
Responding to the report, schools minister Lord Adonis said "the needs of the child should come first and preference of the parents should be given very great weight".

He said: "There should be no question in any locality of special school provision being withdrawn unless the alternative provision being made - whether it be in units, or resource provision attached to school or investment in the mainstream schools - means that those needs can be properly provided for."

He said the government was "investing hugely" in new schools, including special schools.

The committee's recommendation regarding "postcode lottery" of provision would be considered very seriously, Lord Adonis added.

Tory MP Nadine Dorries, a member of the committee, has written her own minority report, saying her colleagues have failed to "identify in sufficient depth" the difficulties faced.

Children were the "innocent victims of an ideologically-driven and dogmatic view with regard to inclusion", she said.

'Wake-up call'

Shadow Education Secretary David Willetts said: "This is a wake-up call to the government which needs to be heeded."

Mother Sam Hall
To know that your child is going into school and they may not be properly supported is really scary for any parent
Sam Hall

Liberal Democrat Education spokesman Stephen Williams said: "The government needs to clear up the confusion it has created over what it means by 'inclusion'.

"Parents need clarity about what their child is entitled to."

The National Autistic Society welcomed the committee¿s "hard-hitting and ambitious" report.

It particularly supported the call on the government to end "its confused message on inclusion".

"Autism is a spectrum condition that encompasses a wide range of abilities and needs and whilst some children do well in a mainstream educational setting, others will benefit from a specialist placement," it said.

So local authorities should provide a range of mainstream and specialist provision.

Another charity, Scope, said 60% of parents it had surveyed felt they had no choice of schools.

Director of Education Andy Lusk said: "Many responses illustrated that parents had to fight for the necessary resources in tribunals to obtain the school of their choice - further proof of the battleground between parents and the system in SEN provision."

A mother's fight for the best education for her autistic sons

Rise in pupils with special needs
22 Jun 06 |  Education
School 'is failing my daughter'
16 May 06 |  Education
Calls for better autism schooling
23 May 06 |  Education
Loophole unfair to young disabled
16 Jun 06 |  Education
School inclusion 'can be abuse'
16 May 06 |  Education
Tories' special needs review call
29 Nov 05 |  Education
Helping the most troubled pupils
11 Feb 04 |  Education

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific