Page last updated at 10:25 GMT, Thursday, 11 March 2010

Police accused of failures over anti-social behaviour

Denis O'Connor: "Some victims (of anti-social behaviour) have harrowing tales"

The way the police in England and Wales deal with complaints of anti-social behaviour has been strongly criticised by the chief inspector of constabulary.

Denis O'Connor said the failure to properly record and tackle incidents undermined confidence in the police, and called for urgent improvements.

His comments came as the inspectorate published "report cards" on the performance of 43 forces.

Nottinghamshire and Greater Manchester received the lowest grades.

Nottinghamshire also recorded the highest rate of violent assaults.

The inspectorate found the way police databases logged information about reports of harassment, vandalism and verbal abuse was "inadequate".


Most police computer systems were unable to identify people who had been victims before or previously categorised as "vulnerable".

Mr O'Connor said: "It is like going back to the doctors' surgery but you see a different doctor every time.

"The more times they suffer, the less confidence people have. There are some heart-rending stories."

What we are asking for is that the decision makers within the police force ensure that decent people are allowed to live their lives in peace and safety
Derrick Campbell
Adviser to Association of Chief Police Officers

He told BBC Radio 4's Today programme at least half of police forces found it "very difficult" to identify repeat victims of anti-social behaviour.

He said being unable to track a pattern of complaints made it hard to tackle the "chronic illness that causes corrosive harm in communities".

The Independent Police Complaints Commission is investigating the case of Fiona Pilkington who killed herself and her severely disabled daughter after suffering sustained anti-social behaviour in Leicestershire.

Police there were called 33 times in seven years to reports of abuse, vandalism and violence by local youths.

Policing minister David Hanson told the BBC one of the lessons of that "tragic case" was to ensure cases were followed up by police and local councils, then tracked.

He said minimum standards were being introduced "across the board" with a new tracking system that would flag up any earlier complaints.

Fiona Pilkington killed herself and her daughter, Francecca
Fiona Pilkington killed herself and her daughter, Francecca, after abuse

"They're low level issues very often, but they can be quite serious and they will blight people's lives and we have a duty to take things seriously," he said.

A survey of forces by the Inspectorate found that in 23% of incidents of anti-social behaviour officers did not turn up.

Almost all the victims in these cases said they were dissatisfied with the explanation given.

Where police did attend, confidence in the police increased.

Mr O'Connor said the distinction between crime and anti-social behaviour was "artificial" and urged police to take it more seriously.

He said: "I think this undermines confidence if it is not dealt with seriously, confidence not just in the police but in general.

"It is partly an individual thing but it also has a wider effect on the community, it adds an air of futility in public."

Derrick Campbell, an adviser to the Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo), told the BBC it was time the issue of anti-social behaviour was made a priority.


"When we see individuals or gangs of individuals terrorising neighbourhoods, stealing cars, throwing stones at windows, the police have a duty to respond," he said.

"What we are asking for is that the decision makers within the police force ensure that decent people are allowed to live their lives in peace and safety and the police are there as an instrument to the state to ensure that that happens."

Acpo president, Sir Hugh Orde, said the problem could only be fully solved with better links between organisations.

"The more we engage with partners, the more we have long-term solutions which actually work," he told the Today programme.

In terms of overall performance, the Inspectorate assessed each constabulary in three categories - local crime and policing; protection from serious harm; confidence and satisfaction.

Nottinghamshire was graded "poor" on all three criteria - the worst-performing force.

It also had the highest number of violent assaults per 1,000 residents - 11.6.

Greater Manchester Police - which had the highest rate of vehicle crime - was adjudged to be performing poorly in two areas, and Lincolnshire was ranked poor in the local crime and police section.


A team of inspectors are closely monitoring developments in Nottinghamshire and GMP to ensure improvements are made.

But Peter Fahy, GMP chief constable, said the HMIC's analysis used data that was five months out of date, and the force had seen "significant achievements" in cutting crime since then.

The top six performers were Cleveland, Hertfordshire, Lancashire, Merseyside, Northumbria and Surrey.

Professor Gloria Laycock, director of the Jill Dando Institute of Security and Crime Science at University College London, said communities needed to take some control.

She said her research from Germany found parents, communities, schools, and teachers took more responsibility than in Britain.

"In the UK, 60% of people said they would do nothing, they felt it was the responsibility of the police, the courts and the parents - and I think that's a really big problem," she told Today.

Overall police performance in England and Wales

Force Local policing Protection from harm Confidence
Avon & Somerset ConstabularyFairFairFair
Bedfordshire PoliceFairFairFair
Cambridgeshire ConstabularyFairFairFair
Cheshire ConstabularyFairFairFair
City of London PoliceFairFairFair
Cleveland PoliceGoodGoodGood
Cumbria ConstabularyGoodFairGood
Derbyshire ConstabularyFairFairFair
Devon & Cornwall ConstabularyGoodGoodFair
Dorset PoliceFairFairFair
Durham ConstabularyFairGoodGood
Dyfed Powys PoliceGoodFairFair
Essex PoliceGoodFairGood
Gloucestershire ConstabularyFairFairFair
Greater Manchester PolicePoorGoodPoor
Gwent PoliceFairGoodFair
Hampshire ConstabularyFairGoodFair
Hertfordshire ConstabularyGoodGoodGood
Humberside PoliceFairFairFair
Kent PoliceGoodGoodFair
Lancashire ConstabularyExcellentFairGood
Leicestershire ConstabularyFairFairFair
Lincolnshire PolicePoorFairFair
Merseyside PoliceGoodExcellentFair
Metropolitan Police ServiceFairExcellentFair
Norfolk ConstabularyGoodGoodFair
North Wales PoliceFairFairFair
North Yorkshire PoliceFairFairFair
Northamptonshire PoliceFairFairFair
Northumbria PoliceGoodGoodGood
Nottinghamshire PolicePoorPoorPoor
South Wales PoliceFairGoodFair
South Yorkshire PoliceFairFairFair
Staffordshire PoliceFairGoodFair
Suffolk ConstabularyFairFairFair
Surrey PoliceGoodGoodGood
Sussex PoliceFairFairFair
Thames Valley PoliceFairFairFair
Warwickshire PoliceFairFairFair
West Mercia PoliceGoodFairGood
West Midlands PoliceFairExcellentFair
West Yorkshire PoliceFairFairFair
Wiltshire PoliceGoodFairFair

Print Sponsor

Under fire force 'failed victim'
11 Mar 10 |  Manchester
Police powers for security staff
24 Feb 10 |  England
Police 'will learn' from deaths
29 Sep 09 |  Leicestershire
'A prisoner in her own home'
29 Sep 09 |  Today

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific