Page last updated at 04:19 GMT, Wednesday, 30 December 2009

Thatcher believed 'never admit anything' was good rule

Margaret Thatcher in 2001
Mrs Thatcher's apparent motto is revealed in National Archive files

"Never admit to anything unless you have to" was apparently a rule that former prime minister Margaret Thatcher liked to live by.

Documents from 1979 released by the National Archives show she used the rule to argue against publishing a book on the secret services.

Other files reveal her efforts to be seen as an equal to male world leaders.

They show that when Japan tried to give her female bodyguards - so-called "karate ladies" - she refused.

'Stick to it'

The newly-released records reveal how different politicians reacted to plans to publish an official history of Britain's intelligence services in World War II.

Prime Minister Jim Callaghan wrote to Mrs Thatcher, then in opposition, and Liberal Party leader David Steel telling them that "[the book] gives credit where credit is due" but does "not attempt to cover up the faults".

Mrs Thatcher will attend the summit not as a woman per se
Cabinet Secretary Sir John Hunt

Mr Steel agreed to publication, but Mrs Thatcher expressed her disquiet, asking: "Do we really have to lay bare to those who could profit from it, not only what intelligence we had, but how we interpreted it?"

She went on: "I was taught a very good rule by two Masters at Law, both of whom are now judges: never admit anything unless you have to; and then only for specific reasons and within defined limits.

"It is a rule that has stood me in very good stead in many a complicated matter, and in the absence of further advice I should be inclined to stick to it now."

Mr Callaghan was also in favour of releasing documents marked with SIS, indicating that the Secret Intelligence Services - MI5 and MI6 - had been involved in their preparation.

But at the time, the policy of the British government was to deny the existence of the secret services - and Mrs Thatcher wanted to stick to that.

Letter from Margaret Thatcher to Jim Callaghan (Pic: National Archives)
Mrs Thatcher wrote to Jim Callaghan expressing her "disquiet"

She said the publication of the documents would be "the thin end of a dangerous wedge".

In his reply, Mr Callaghan admitted it would "make it the more unrealistic to maintain the fiction that this organisation does not exist at present".

But he insisted: "This would be on the very clear understanding that avowal that the service exists should not result in giving way to any pressures to answer questions about it."

'Karate ladies'

Another file released by the archives gives a glimpse at how the arrival of a female head of government opened up a new minefield in diplomatic etiquette.

Ahead of the Tokyo international summit in June 1979, a document from the government's Protocol and Conference Department revealed that Japanese authorities were planning to provide 20 "karate ladies" - specialist female bodyguards - to attend to her.

Margaret Thatcher alongside other world leaders in 1990
Mrs Thatcher was a lone female on the global political stage

But a letter from the Lord Privy Seal to the Foreign Office made clear Cabinet Secretary Sir John Hunt's view that "Mrs Thatcher will attend the summit as prime minister and not as a woman per se".

It continued: "The prime minister would like to be treated in exactly the same manner as the other visiting heads of delegation; it is not the degree of protection that is in question, but the particular means of carrying it out.

"If other delegation leaders, for example, are each being assigned 20 karate gentlemen, the prime minister would have no objection to this; but she does not wish to be singled out.

"She has not had in the past and does not have now any female Special Branch officers."



Print Sponsor


RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

BBC navigation

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific