Page last updated at 10:48 GMT, Monday, 7 September 2009 11:48 UK

Does brain training really work?

Advertisement

Today presenter Evan Davis has his brain scanned

By Dr Adrian Owen
Medical Research Council, Cognition and Brain Sciences Unit

Brain training is a billion dollar industry, but does it actually work? The BBC is launching Britain's biggest ever brain training experiment to find out.

Millions of copies of console and computer-based "brain trainers" are sold worldwide every year, claiming to make peoples' brains younger, better, faster or bigger.

The theory seems to make sense: regularly exercising the brain with tests and puzzles can improve brain skills and help people become better at everyday thinking tasks.

But recent research suggests scientific evidence is lacking.

The BBC's Brain Test Britain experiment wants to find out if brain training really works, and is aiming to get thousands of members of the public to train for 10 minutes a day, three times a week, for at least six weeks.

There are five main problems with current research:

1. SCIENTIFIC CLAIMS 'NOT PROPERLY CHECKED'
puzzle of four flowers
Which flower is the odd one out? The answer is the square, the second one

Scientific experiments and their findings should be evaluated by independent experts in a process called "peer review". This is the minimum standard by which the quality of any research is judged.

Very little research on commercial brain trainers has been peer reviewed.

Instead, manufacturers often link to white papers and conference reports, or quote unsupported testimonials from "satisfied users".

None of these are acceptable substitutes for peer review.

2. BRAIN IMAGING 'NOT PROOF'
Brain MRI
Dr Jessica Grahn said scans only showed the energy the brain used

Several companies use pictures of brains lighting up to support claims that their brain training is effective.

Brain scans and other imaging may look good, but what do they really show?

It is a very persuasive technique, but in reality only shows how hard the brain is working, rather than how effective the training is.

Dr Jessica Grahn, a neuro-imaging expert at the Medical Research Council Cognition and Brain Sciences Unit, said: "What we are looking at with these brain scans is simply a measure of the energy that the brain is using while performing the tests.

"It does not constitute evidence that the brain is being trained, or indeed altered, in any way."

3. CONTROL GROUPS

Logic puzzle asking which is heaviest object on a see-saw
Which is the heaviest object on the see-saw? The answer is the hexagon

A proper "control group" is the backbone of any valid scientific study.

Without a control group, it is hard to tell whether results are down to brain training, or simply because the participant is doing something - anything - to stimulate their brain.

With a brain training study, the control group of participants should do the same amount of a mental activity as the brain-training group, but using a "non-brain training" activity such as a crossword or Sudoku.

Scientists should then be able to compare the results from the two groups to see how genuinely effective the brain training tasks were.

BRAIN TRAINERS
Nintendo DS
Mindfit (PC)
Luminosity (online)
Mindspa

Studies that have been used to support the claims made by commercial brain trainers often have no control group at all, or a control group that is not as mentally active as the trained group.

4. THE BENCHMARKING TEST

In order to see how much you have improved, you need to know where you were at the start. To do this, scientists use a "benchmarking test" - the same test, taken at the beginning and end of an experiment.

Studies used to support the claims made by commercial brain trainers often use tests for benchmarking that are identical - or very similar - to the tests used during training.

Tetris
Research has suggested Tetris can help reduce traumatic stress

But all this proves is that practice makes perfect: if you played Tetris for a month and got better at it, should we conclude that playing Tetris is a useful form of brain training? Probably not.

Benchmarking tests should be different from the brain training tasks. This way, scientists can see if the effects of brain training are transferable to other mental tasks.

If you played Tetris for a month and found, say, your memory was suddenly much better, it would indicate that playing Tetris has improved your brain in some way other than making you good at Tetris.

5. WHAT WORKS FOR ONE MIGHT NOT WORK FOR ANOTHER

Bang Goes The Theory's presenters got good results

Does the research show the brain trainer is effective in participants who are similar to you?

Just because a system claims to improve the memory of a group of elderly participants, for example, it does not necessarily mean that it will have the same - or indeed any - effect in younger users.

The BBC's Brain Test Britain experiment, created with the Medical Research Council's Cognition and Brain Sciences Unit and the Alzheimer's Society, has made sure it meets all the accepted standards for a scientifically valid study.

Find out more about the Brain Test Britain experiment at the BBC's
Bang Goes The Theory website or watch the programme on BBC one Monday 7 September 1930 BST.



Print Sponsor


SEE ALSO
What are the benefits of Tetris?
03 Sep 09 |  Magazine
'Brain training' claims dismissed
26 Feb 09 |  Health
Knitting 'can delay' memory loss
18 Feb 09 |  Health
Invaluable support of memory clinic
03 Feb 09 |  Health
Tetris 'helps to reduce trauma'
07 Jan 09 |  Health
Mind games
06 Sep 07 |  Magazine

RELATED BBC LINKS


FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

BBC navigation

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific