Page last updated at 17:28 GMT, Sunday, 23 August 2009 18:28 UK

MoD budget 'harm' claims denied

UK troops and a Chinook helicopter
There is an ongoing political row about equipment for troops

Armed Forces Minister Bill Rammell has denied claims that soldiers' lives are being put at risk by inefficient MoD systems for buying new equipment.

A report leaked to the Sunday Times suggested the problems were "harming our ability" to conduct operations.

According to the paper current MoD aquisition projects are £35bn over budget and five years behind schedule.

Mr Rammell insisted: "Lives are not being put at risk as a result of the procurement process."

But he added: "Nevertheless it is critically important that we constantly seek to get the best value for money in what is an enormous equipment purchase programme.

"That's why we asked for this work to be done; we asked for the report, we will respond to it."

The report was originally commissioned by John Hutton, who resigned as defence secretary in June, and it was due to be published in July.

It seems as though military equipment acquisition is vying in a technological race with the delivery of civilian software systems for the title of 'world's most delayed technical solution'
Bernard Gray, report author

The MoD said it was working on the problems detailed in the draft report.

The Sunday Times said the report's author Bernard Gray, a former government adviser, had called the problems "endemic".

The newspaper claims to have seen the full 296-page report and it highlights a number of Mr Gray's comments from the review.

"How can it be that it takes 20 years to buy a ship, or aircraft, or tank? Why does it always seem to cost at least twice what was thought?"

"Even worse, at the end of the wait, why does it never quite seem to do what it was supposed to?"

'Agile enemies'

He concluded the current programme was unaffordable in the long term and the MoD's procurement section should be privatised.

"The problems, and the sums of money involved, have almost lost their power to shock, so endemic is the issue," wrote Mr Gray.

"It seems as though military equipment acquisition is vying in a technological race with the delivery of civilian software systems for the title of 'world's most delayed technical solution'. Even British trains cannot compete."

The report warns the MoD has a "substantially overheated equipment programme, with too many types of equipment being ordered for too large a range of tasks at too high a specification".

Agile enemies such as the Taliban were "unlikely to wait for our sclerotic acquisition systems to catch up", he said.

Shadow defence secretary Liam Fox described the report as "very damning"

The Gray dossier also found delays in the shipbuilding programme meant Britain could not have fought a Falklands-style campaign any time over the past 20 years.

"We would have risked significant casualties, the very significant costs of acquiring adequate equipment at short notice (if available) or the embarrassment of not fighting at all," he said.

An MoD spokesman said Mr Gray's work would "feed into" its recently announced defence green paper and the government would publish the report in "due course".

"We are constantly improving the procurement process which has seen us deliver £10 billion of equipment to the front line over the last three years," he added.

'Confidence trick'

Parts of the report had already been leaked and the BBC's political correspondent Laura Kuenssberg said its findings were expected to be critical.

But it was understood the government had decided not to go ahead with publication because the conclusions were so stark, she added.

Shadow defence secretary Liam Fox described the report as "very damning".

Mr Fox told the BBC: "It's not clear now to any of us what the size of the black hole is; and whether in fact our whole defence budget is some sort of confidence trick which tells us we are going to have equipment in the future, for which no money has been put aside.

"It's simply not good enough for the government to suppress a report of this importance."

Political row

The leaked dossier is likely to fuel the ongoing political row over equipment levels for troops, which have particularly focused on helicopters.

Last month, the Commons defence select committee said a lack of helicopters was undermining UK forces' operations and troop protection in Afghanistan, where the British death toll has now reached 206.

Criticism has also come from within the government's own ranks and the head of the Army, General Sir Richard Dannatt, has called for better equipment to protect troops from roadside bombs in Afghanistan.

But the government has repeatedly insisted the Army has enough equipment and denied claims of a helicopter shortage.

Print Sponsor

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Guardian Unlimited We've blown the defence budget - 3 hrs ago
Times Online Ministry of Defence's 'disastrous' decision... - 8 hrs ago
National Post U.K. government mothballs helicopters after it fails to program software for them - 17 hrs ago
Telegraph The Army is too small to fight all of the battles facing Britain - 22 hrs ago
New Zealand Herald Report blasts defence buying - 25 hrs ago

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2020 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific