Page last updated at 12:28 GMT, Wednesday, 20 May 2009 13:28 UK

When love becomes fatal obsession

By Chris Summers
BBC News

When his 15-year-old girlfriend dumped him after complaining about his controlling behaviour, Thomas Nugusse's love developed into an obsession that led to her death.

Arsema Dawit's mother is comforted by a friend
Arsema's mother (centre) was overwhelmed with grief after the killing

Arsema Dawit was a choirgirl at an Eritrean Orthodox Church when she met Nugusse.

He was older, also of Eritrean origin and attended the same church in Camberwell, south London.

For two years he was her boyfriend, but his possessive and controlling behaviour became too much for her.

On 16 April 2008 he punched her at a McDonald's restaurant in Walworth, blackening her eye, after she said hello to a male friend.

It was the final straw and she broke off the relationship.

Her mother, Tsehaynesh Medhani, called in the police, but Arsema was unwilling to file a formal complaint.

Stabbed

Ms Medhani feared for her daughter and tried to ensure she was escorted home from school every day.

But Nugusse told Arsema's mother: "How many days are you going to accompany her? I'll kill her one day."

He kept his word on 2 June 2008.

An Old Bailey jury was shown CCTV footage of Nugusse following her into the block of flats near Waterloo station where she lived.

Arsema Dawit
Arsema Dawit had chosen not to pursue a complaint against Nugusse

She was stabbed more than 30 times, mainly in the neck, and her body was found 20 minutes later by a neighbour, returning home after picking up her eight-year-old daughter from school.

Nugusse, a 22-year-old civil engineering student, from Ilford, Essex, walked to nearby Hungerford Bridge and made a 999 call.

He immediately confessed to what he had done, but tellingly he appeared unaware Arsema had ended their relationship and continued to refer to her as "my girlfriend".

He threatened to jump into the River Thames. For 35 minutes the operator kept him on the phone, until police officers finally located and arrested him.

Two weeks later Nugusse tried to hang himself in his cell. He was cut free but had suffered severe brain damage.

Unable to communicate with his lawyers, he was declared unfit for trial. Judge Peter Beaumont said it would be a "heartless act" to make him attend court.

So this week a jury at the Old Bailey was shown the overwhelming evidence against him and, after a brief "trial of issue", decided he was responsible for Arsema's death.

He was ordered to be detained indefinitely under a hospital order in secure conditions.

Doctors are pessimistic about him ever regaining his mental faculties.

Previous cases

The case, which follows the deaths in similar circumstances of Clare Bernal, Tania Moore and Rana Faruqui, highlights the police's continuing inability to protect female victims of male violence.

The scene of the stabbing
The teenager's body was found in the lift by a neighbour

The Independent Police Complaints Commission said that, now the criminal trial was over, it would be continuing its investigation into the allegations that the original assault had not been treated seriously enough.

Mrs Medhani said she awaited the outcome of the investigation and added "I believe Arsema's life could have been saved if the police had taken action when I approached them".

She also said: "My body is alive but my spirit is dead and I feel with her death I died too.

"It would have been better if the murderer had taken all our lives, not just Arsema's, as we have not been able to live our lives since that terrible day."

Paul Infield, a barrister and author of The Law of Harassment and Stalking, told BBC News: "The problem for the police and the CPS is how to know which of the approximately 880,000 stalking cases each year are going to become murders.

"Risk assessment is probably the best way of making that distinction. For the ordinary copper on the ground, how does he know which ones to investigate and which ones to ignore?"

Mr Infield said: "If you locked up every budding Lothario who had phoned up a girl too many times the jails would be full. But 80% of stalkers are men and a lot of those do become dangerously obsessed, and it can be very scary, especially for young women."

He said research in Britain, Australia and the US suggested that a warning or a caution from a police officer tended to stop stalking but only "if it happens before the obsessive behaviour becomes ingrained".

Mr Infield said it was understandable that a 15-year-old girl might not want to press charges and she clearly never foresaw what would happen.

It is very difficult to stop somebody like this because they will deny and minimise their actions
Dr Lorraine Sheridan

Dr Lorraine Sheridan, a psychologist and expert on stalking from Heriot-Watt University in Edinburgh, said: "Most of the dangerous stalkers are not mentally ill and do not suffer from conditions like schizophrenia. They simply have an inability to cope with rejection.

"They feel the victim is controlling them because they can't get her out of their heads and sometimes they feel the only way out of the pain is to kill them. They will often then try to kill themselves."

She said she knew of some stalking cases that had lasted 40 years.

Dr Sheridan has been working with the Association of Chief Police Officers on new risk assessment protocols about to be rolled out across the country.

Clare Bernal
Clare Bernal was shot dead by an ex-boyfriend in Harvey Nichols in London

She said police forces were getting much better in the way they dealt with stalking cases but added: "Part of the problem is that it is very difficult to stop somebody like this because they will deny and minimise their actions.

"They will often believe the victim deserves it and deny they have a problem."

The CRT (Clare, Rana and Tania) Trust was set up to campaign for more action on stalkers.

One of its members, Tracey Morgan, said: "Stalking/harassment is not a minor crime.

"This must be dealt with as murder prevention so that background checks and assessments on the alleged perpetrators are to hand and they are not released on bail or given sentences that will effectively put victims more at risk, resulting in inadequate or no protection.

"This country needs a sea change in attitude so that the human rights and life of a victim is put above that of the perpetrator."

Killer's 999 stab confession

Edited excerpts from Nugusse's 999 call from Hungerford Bridge:

Operator: "Hello?"

Nugusse: "OK [inaudible] I want to tell you that I, I, I had a fight with my girlfriend and I killed my girlfriend so this is because [inaudible]."

Operator: "What's her name?"

Nugusse: "Arsema."

Operator: "Why did you kill her?"

Nugusse: "Because she cheating me. She been with me for two years and then she went with some guy."

Operator: "But what do you plan to do, jump in the river?"

Nugusse: "Yeah, I just want to finish myself."

Operator: "There's no point ending two lives over this. I understand you're very upset."

Nugusse: "It's OK, just [inaudible] what do you expect, that I kill my girlfriend and I want to live?"

Operator: "No I understand that, but maybe you could talk to the police, you said you loved her... and we could salvage something from this."

Nugusse: "This is not possible. Yeah I do love her and I can't live without her."



Print Sponsor


RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

BBC navigation

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific