Page last updated at 16:27 GMT, Monday, 12 January 2009

Prince's apology genuine, says PM

Prince Harry, smiling at the Queen, and Ahmed Raza Khan, bottom right, at their Sandhurst passing out parade in 2006.
Prince Harry and Ahmed Raza Khan, bottom, at Sandhurst in 2006

Gordon Brown has said he believes the British public will give Prince Harry the "benefit of the doubt" after he apologised for using racist language.

Mr Brown told GMTV he saw Harry's apology as genuine, after the prince was captured on film calling a fellow cadet "our little Paki friend" in 2006.

Labour MP Keith Vaz said the term was "unacceptable and wounding".

The defence secretary said Harry's commanding officer was likely to speak to the prince in the next few days.

John Hutton told the Commons: "We should not lose sight of one very important fact in all this, that Prince Harry has served his country on active service in Afghanistan and I believe very strongly that there is no better example of public service than that."

The comment was in a home video Prince Harry made when he was an officer cadet in 2006 and which was obtained by a Sunday newspaper.

'Role model'

Speaking on GMTV, the prime minister said his comments had "no part in our life".

"It was a mistake and he's made the admission of that..." he said.

"... the British people are good enough to give someone who has actually been a role model for young people and who has done well fighting for our country... the benefit of the doubt," Mr Brown said.

Although he did not think Prince Harry was a racist, Labour MP Keith Vaz told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that he should spend more time with his father, who had "shown how much can be done to build relations between communities".

"We cannot use language of this kind, even in jest," he said.

"He is not an understudy for Bernard Manning. He is third in line to the throne; he is a role model."

Rod Richards, who served as a Foreign Office minister in former prime minister John Major's Conservative government and also as an officer in the Royal Marines, defended the prince on the Today programme.

He said he regarded "Paki" as an abbreviation, and the prince, in his view, had "not crossed the line".

Welshman Mr Richards added that he was frequently called "Taffy" in the Army, and even in the House of Commons a colleague used to make references to him "having sexual relations with sheep".

'Hate word'

The father of the soldier involved has also criticised the prince for using what he called a "hate word".

Muhammad Yaqoob Khan Abbasi spoke to the Daily Mail from his home in Pakistan, and condemned the prince's comment about his son, Ahmed Raza Khan.

Ethnic minorities
October 2008 - 6.3% or 12,088 personnel in the Armed Forces were from an ethnic minority
April 2008 - 6.1% or 11, 753
October 2007 - 5.9% or 11, 434
April 2007 - 5.8% or 11, 349
April 2006 - 5.5% or 11, 058
April 2005 - 5.3% or 10, 943
Source: Ministry of Defence

He told the newspaper: "When I saw the video I was very, very hurt. I strongly condemn the fact that Prince Harry used that language against my son.

"That word he used is a hate word and should never be used against any Pakistani.

"Prince Harry should apologise to the Pakistani Army and to the Pakistani government for this. I cannot accept his apology unless they first accept his apology."

In the Commons, Labour MP Diane Abbott said it would be a "shame" if the incident undermined efforts in the military to recruit from "diverse communities".

And Labour MP Harry Cohen suggested the prince's comments would deter people of Pakistani origin from joining the military.

Exactly WHEN is it acceptable to refer to someone by the colour of their skin or their background?
Maria, Gillingham

In response, the defence secretary said: "The armed forces will tackle discrimination wherever it rears its ugly and unacceptable head, and we have shown that we are prepared to do that."

The Army said it would not launch a formal investigation into the matter because no complaint had been made.

But a spokesman said: "The Army does not tolerate inappropriate behaviour in any shape or form.

"The Army takes all allegations of inappropriate behaviour very seriously and all substantive allegations are investigated. This specific case will be dealt with in line with normal army procedures."


It is understood the prince's swift apology and the length of time since the offence will be taken into account and he could simply face a dressing down.

The prince also came in for criticism for another video clip in which he described a fellow Army cadet as a "raghead".

The Army has been trying to recruit soldiers from ethnic minority backgrounds as these are currently under-represented in the services.

The latest figures, as of 1 October 2008, show ethnic minorities accounted for 6.3% of UK regular forces, or 12,088, compared to 5.9% (11,434) the previous October.

Print Sponsor

Profile: Prince Harry
11 Jan 09 |  UK
After the N-word, the P-word
11 Jun 07 |  Magazine

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific