BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Page last updated at 15:46 GMT, Thursday, 22 November 2007

At-a-glance: Heathrow's rivals

Those in favour of a third runway and sixth terminal at Heathrow often cite expansion as the only way the world's busiest international airport can continue to compete with its rivals on the European continent.

While in passenger terms, Heathrow continues to be Europe's dominant airport, its owners BAA argue that unless its infrastructure is upgraded, then it will fall behind the airports of Amsterdam, Frankfurt and Paris.

LONDON HEATHROW

When Hounslow Heath opened as the new London airport in 1946, few who checked in at the temporary tented village before boarding their converted WWII bomber could have envisaged it becoming a global aviation hub.

Its development since then has never really stopped.

Heathrow Terminal 4 check-in
Heathrow Terminal 4 was opened in 1986

For almost every decade since, a new terminal has opened at Heathrow - from the first in 1955 (now known as Terminal 2) to Terminal 5 next year - but its two parallel runways have been in use since the 50s.

Having two runways puts Heathrow at a disadvantage over its competitors. With one in use for take-offs, and one for landings, the number of aircraft that can land and depart remains constrained.

But the size of the site, the smallest of the European "big four" at 1214ha (3000 acres), means there is no chance of developing another runway within the airport's boundaries.

Therefore, the only way Heathrow could match its rivals is to build in a densely-populated area - and it is this which engenders vehement opposition.

Despite this, Heathrow is the world's third busiest airport (its owners say it is the world's busiest international airport) with 67.7m passengers passing through its four terminals in 2006.

AMSTERDAM SCHIPHOL

The grand-daddy of Europe's biggest hubs at 87 years old, Amsterdam Schiphol is praised by travellers for its integrated terminal.

While a change at Heathrow could see a traveller making an underground hike to get to their next flight, Schiphol has always played on its easy connections.

Schiphol departure lounge
Amsterdam Schiphol began life as a military airfield in 1916

Development at Amsterdam has focused on maintaining the one terminal format, although the original 1967 development was more than doubled in size by 1975.

While the airport does not have Heathrow's dominant position in terms of passenger numbers (46.1m in 2006), it tops the league for runways.

Five have been built since the first tarmac landing strip was laid in 1938. The latest, completed in 2003, was constructed on marshland four miles (seven km) from the terminal.

Its position is also intended to reduce noise pollution for Amsterdam and communities near the airport.

FRANKFURT MAIN

With two terminals and three runways, Frankfurt's answer to a forecast growth in passenger numbers to 88.3m by 2020 is similar to that facing BAA at Heathrow.

Fraport, who own the airport, want to build a new runway and a new terminal.

Aircraft at Frankfurt
Lufthansa is the dominant airline at Frankfurt Main

And like Heathrow, the argument for the landing strip is to provide more slots for arriving aircraft and reduce delays.

But the German capital Berlin - which does not have a major air hub the size of Heathrow, Schiphol or Frankfurt - is going its own way in providing a new rival.

Berlin's Schonefeld airport, formerly East Germany's main hub, is being re-developed to become Berlin Brandenburg International. Its backers predict it will be able to handle 20m passengers a year once it is completed in 2011.

PARIS CHARLES DE GAULLE

The massive 3238 hectare (8000 acre) site at Roissy, north of Paris, is held up as either the way to develop a major international hub - or as a monstrous use of land in the name of aviation.

Terminal 2F at Charles de Gaulle
Terminal 2 is divided into six different mini-terminals

Initially opened as a one-terminal airport in 1974 - Charles de Gaulle won plaudits for its cylindrical Terminal 1 design.

CDG now has four runways, and three terminals, handling 56.6m passengers a year.

Recent figures suggest the runways are operating at less than 75% of their capacity, compared to 98.5% at Heathrow.

How Heathrow compares with Europe

  Heathrow Amsterdam Schiphol Frankfurt Main Paris Charles de Gaulle
Opened 1946 1920 1936 1974
Runways 2 6 3 4
Terminals 4 (5 by 2008) 1 2 3
Movements
per year
469,560 423,000 482,000 533,000
Passengers
per year
67.7m 46.1m 52.8m 56.6m
Land area 1214ha 2787ha 2000ha 3238ha
World rank (by passengers) 3 12 8 7
Sources: BAA, Fraport, Schiphol Group, ADP, ACI



video and audio news
Planes landing at Heathrow Airport





FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific