|You are in: UK|
Monday, 27 March, 2000, 15:14 GMT 16:14 UK
Britain singled out as lonely nation
A steady decline in marriages coupled with rising divorce rates has revealed that Britain may be turning into a nation of loners.
A study published on Monday reports that fewer people are now getting married than at any time in the past 40 years. The independent Family Policy Studies Centre (FPSC) findings show that more than 6.5 million people in Britain - about 28% of households - now live on their own, three times as many as 40 years ago.
Rising numbers of step families, older people, single lone mothers and fewer children also point to a decline in the traditional family unit.
In 1961 approximately 333,000 first time marriages and remarriages took place.
In 1997 these figures had dropped to less than 200,000 first time marriages and around 120,000 remarriages.
During the same period the divorce rate increased from 50,000 to 100,000.
The annual cost of family breakdowns on the public purse is estimated at around £5bn.
FPSC director Ceridwen Roberts said the statistics indicated that marriage and partners were "much more fragile than they were".
"Families are becoming smaller, fewer people are marrying and increasing numbers of children are being born outside marriage," she said.
"To date, the focus has been on the effect these changes will have on children. The impact right across the life cycle, including on the growing numbers of older people, must be fully taken on board.
"Government policies must take more account of the changing family to meet family needs and aspirations in the 21st century."
Disclaimer: The BBC will put up as many of your comments as possible but we cannot guarantee that all e-mails will be published. The BBC reserves the right to edit comments that are published.
As a single 27-year-old and a touch lonely (at least subconsciously), I can't help but feel that many of correspondents to this debate are a little disillusioned, bitter or in a state of denial about there priorities in life. In essence, most of us want love, marriage, children and security. I would certainly trade my so-called 'independence' for a commitment to giving and sharing without hesitation.
Try living in California, this is the loneliest place in the planet, no one is social at all. Compared to when I was in the UK I find it the last place to find loners, just more independent people wanting to have a laugh and less of the heavy serious life stuff.
Dr. K-K. Chan, UK
With the scant choice of social places to meet people - is it any wonder?
Deafening night-clubs, smoky and stuffy pubs, rip-off so-called "meet-your-dream-partner" phone lines and so-called dating agencies are contribute to make England a waste of time and money when it comes to dating. The solution? Move abroad!
As a frequent visitor to the UK I have noticed that most of my friends, both male and female seem to live on their own. However I don't think that I would call them lonely. I think that many people are starting to reject the age old myth that without someone else in your life you are only half a person.
Ian Eustace, England
It's very simple really, society is evolving. People have far more freedom of choice about their lifestyle than they have had in the past, and they are choosing. Tradition is the democracy of the dead, they do not have to live in today's society, and should not therefore be allowed to vote.
Living alone is a side-effect of the modern age, which I am not wholly happy with, probably because it has effected me for quite some time!
I think living alone is fine, I have lived alone and am very happy. I feel that too much emphasis is put on being in a partnership. I think the saddest individuals are the ones who have to cement themselves in a relationship because they are too feeble to stand on their own two feet.
Veronica Williamson, The Netherlands
Is it surprising that the younger generations have become apathetic to the institution of marriage after the mockery our parent's generation have made of it?
Whatever situation one chooses there is nothing worse than to get married just because it is expected of one by parents, religion, culture etc. So if you are alone good luck, it's every bit as good a way of life as being married or living together.
Steve Foley, England
I did not always know it, but others brand me odd because
of my bookish/studious life style.
Others that think they command great
knowledge of right and wrong are usually too impatient to reason things out. To my mind we need to be more tolerant
with our selves and others.
Humans are social animals, and we need each other. This is what makes us so special, and the driving force that made us shape the world to what it is today. Failing to recognise this fundamental truth may prove to be more destructive to our society than the apocalypse.
Although I'm unmarried (and quite happy that way) it bugs me when people say that financially they will be no better off if they get married. When getting married it should be for reasons other than financial gain.
Maybe the words of the service should be changed to "'till divorce do us part". Or change a few words here and there to reflect that it is an aspiration not a commitment. What is far more important is the commitment a parent gives to their children. Maybe the new service should mention the individual responsibility that each parent has to the children of the union.
Gordon Lewis, UK
I think that the trend is very, very sad. Society will come to deeply regret the results of telling women that they can have both a career and a family. I truly believe that a major contribution to the ridiculously high divorce rate is the falsely increased expectations of women.
As two single people you can have two mortgages at 3 times your individual salaries.
As a married couple you can only buy a property worth 2.5 times your joint income.
Getting married costs around £10,000. The government has abolished married couples tax allowance.
In effect we penalise marriage in this country.
John Alexander Kral, Sweden
As ever, broad statistics don't necessarily tell the whole story. For example, what percentage of people remain "alone" for more than, say, a year? Is it possible that the increasing percentage of "loners" indicates a desire to "reflect" on what kind of relationship and with whom to partake rather than immediately dive into another as was once required, particularly of women, by the norms of the community.
A real relationship is about sharing, giving and being prepared to compromise. These are things that come from loving each other. Adultery, marriage break-up and people turning their back on their moral responsibilities are the kind of things that the media values. Why? Because a whole industry of gossip and titillation can be made from this.
With the government taking away the married couples allowance there is no incentive to get married. Also, lawyers make so much from a divorce by making people ask for ridiculous amounts, even when there are no children involved.
Flippant She-Creature, Britain
Successive governments have long paid lip service to promoting "family values". When will it finally be understood that programmes and public funds are needed to effectively promote the family?
Not getting married does *not* equal being alone, or living alone. There are many reasons why couples choose not to get married - one is even because the law doesn't allow many couples to get married (same sex couples, for instance).
My girlfriend's parents are still married after 30 years, and have proved to me that there is hope in the institution of marriage. There are however, no benefits, or pressures for us to get married. We are extremely happy living the life we lead. Marriage can not be the same as it was in the 60s because of the rise in divorces, which ultimately changes the lives and attitudes of the children brought up in single parent households. The World is full of opportunities, many people just want a taste - Why get married?
It seems to me that the British government is too eager to award single parents. With rising house prices and the cost of living it seems easier now for young females to fall pregnant and then be rewarded with a house and good income from the government whilst the father of the child gets away scott free.
I believe the current situation is essentially an upshot of the war of the sexes that began when women tried to redress the extreme imbalance of power 30 years ago. Women declared their independence and today we have an entire generation of young men who have become completely disenchanted with society and regard "looking out for number one" as the only valid strategy for modern life. Many young men I know have very low expectations from relationships with women indeed.
Let's face it - the main reason for family stability historically has been economic. As people, and especially women, have become more financially independent it raises the bar that any prospective partners have to vault. People have simply become more choosy, both individually and collectively, because they can afford to be. How politicians think they can reverse the trends by preaching "Family Values" escapes me.
The government is doing nothing to help single educated people in getting married.
I work in East London as a newly qualified EHO earning a gross salary of £23,500 p.a. but this is not enough to enable me to afford to buy a decent house even in the "poor" east end.
With children and young adults being taught to be more career focused, relationships become less important in their lives. Getting married is forever seen as something to do in later life. When people do start thinking of getting married, they have become so ingrained in a single life that the sacrifices and commitment needed to make a successful marriage are no longer high priorities - instead the highest priority is the preservation of a way of life that has been established over many years.
Andrew Milne, Kuwait
As one of those living alone I find it neither sad nor lonely. I am single (not separated or divorced).
and I find very little time to feel lonely looking after two horses, two cats, eight hens, four ducks and a large garden seems to keep me pleasantly occupied with sufficient time available for the occasional visit to the pub and to do some cooking.
Describing Britons as a Nation of loners is a bit over the top. Not getting married does not qualify everyone as a loner!!!
Alex Chiang, Australia
Living alone? I can't remember the last argument I had with myself. We get along really well, me and myself.
The English tax system no longer supports the family (removed married couple allowance). Abolishing MIRAS and harmonising rights between married and single persons have further eroded the advantages to setting up a home as a family unit. If the government do not see the family as being the basis on which to build a stable society is it any wonder that the concept of the traditional family is being abandoned? Jim Lynch, UK
Living alone for women in their 40s and older is often a positive choice - with busy careers, running a family (particularly where the man is a "traditional" one) is seen as just too much extra work. Perhaps the advent of "new man" will change this.
Jeremy French, UK
I live with my partner but the tax laws are such that we would lose out financially if we married. Also we've watched too many people tear themselves apart getting out of unhappy marriages to put such an unnecessary strain on our happy and solid relationship.
Independence is not so important but where is the benefit in getting married?
This may all sound rather selfish and in a way it is but I get really angry at being characterised as a sad lonely person by all those so called happily married families. Many of the families I visit seem to live in a pressure cooker of ever competing desires.
Iwan Turzanski, Netherlands
The increase of people choosing to live alone means that women are in control of the lives, because the may get married does not mean that they become the property of the husband and change to his will.
These days, more women wish to take advantage of equal job opportunities to the extent that many become highly qualified and professional. Likewise, they come to enjoy the independence and self reliance that this brings. Whilst neither sex amongst professionals are totally against matrimony, marriage and starting their own families are often delayed because both sides want to establish themselves first.
Deborah Alphonso, England
Britain is most certainly turning into a nation of loners, but not for the reasons which everyone maintain. Marriages are breaking down more and more due to the fact that many are putting themselves first before thinking about the needs or aspirations of their partners. If we were to take less from our relationships and became more receptive, giving to the relationship, we would stop being loners and greatly increase the chances of relationships lasting a lot longer.
Years ago it was a lot harder to end a marriage and couples were more willing to try and work it out.
Jenny Deione, England
It's just plain sad.
Look at the suicide statistics,
look at the average health of single
people. Look at the despair on the
It's just very very sad.
Britain is not a nation of loners it's
the nation of the lonely. We are sold
an image of true love (in songs by
moronic boy bands, TV soaps and
dramas) that is never realistic or
Graham Lancaster, United Kingdom
One of the main problems these days is that many people are not willing to commit themselves to someone else and be willing to sacrifice their own personal desires for the sake of their partner. Society has become very self-centred and has taken hold of the view that "What I want is what counts most".
Expectations and individual freedoms, long enjoyed by men, are now being extended (quite rightly) to women. However, with neither side prepared to compromise in various aspects of their relationship the likelihood of successful partnerships is dramatically reducing. Unless some form of respectful compromise is reached (and is promoted as "the way to a successful partnership") the situation can only get worse.
I think people should do what makes them happy, and if you are so happy you want to tell people how good your situation is that great. But don't tell other people they are in the wrong because they don't chose the same lifestyle as you.
Les James, Scotland
I agree that Britain is becoming increasingly lonelier. People are more likely to move away from their friends, family and communities in the search for jobs. They end up in big cities not knowing anyone and feeling lonely. Home entertainment doesn't do much to encourage traditional social activities either.
It is very difficult to say that living alone is a bad thing per se, as everybody has different expectations and needs. However, what is true, is that for most people the family unit is the most suitable and effective way of providing the support you need throughout your life. Unfortunately, not enough is being done to preserve this well-evolved structure, and many would argue that the moral and social decay we have been through in recent years, can be directly attributed to this cause.
As one of my colleges has commented, these days you may as well just find someone you don't like, buy them a house, give them £100k and save all the hassle of the relationship which they aren't prepared to make work anyway. Long live singles.
Tim G, UK
Since women are now more financially independent, they no longer have to rely on men for a life, and therefore are living without us. Basically that's it.
If men and women took more time out to discover themselves and their likes and dislikes they may be in a better position to find a suitable partner and build a more meaningful relationship. Either that or get a cat!
Abolition of married couples allowance is just a symptom of how little value is placed on encouraging the institution of marriage. I've been married over 20 years but I'm beginning to think that I would be better off if my wife and I "lived in sin".
Andrew Duncan, UK
27 Mar 00 | UK
10 Feb 00 | UK
24 Jan 00 | UK
04 Nov 99 | UK
08 Feb 99 | Health
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
Top UK stories now:
Links to more UK stories are at the foot of the page.
|E-mail this story to a friend|
Links to more UK stories
To BBC Sport>> | To BBC Weather>> | To BBC World Service>>
© MMIII | News Sources | Privacy