BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: UK
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Friday, 11 August, 2000, 14:40 GMT 15:40 UK
Selling a dark past

Nazi auctions: Historical interest or dudious trade?
Anoraks and enthusiasts poring over mass-produced badges, musty jackets or scraps of paper sounds innocuous enough, were these items not the remnants of Nazi Germany.

The dispute involving Yahoo! in the French court comes after a highly publicised sale of notes written by Hitler for a speech to the Reichstag in 1939 highlighted the market for Nazi memorabilia.

At an auction in Swindon, Wiltsire, in March, "pointer cards" went under the hammer for 11,700.
Red Army soldier with Hitler statue
Many Allied soldiers found mementoes in Berlin
The six postcard-sized sheets, containing threats to the Jews, were put up for sale by 79-year-old Wing Commander Ronald Mason.

As a young airman in newly captured Berlin, he traded some cigarettes for the documents.

Dominic Winter Book Auctions handled the sale of the cards, along with a catalogue of other Nazi era lots.

The surfacing of mementoes "liberated" by Allied servicemen has helped fuel a roaring trade in Nazi items.

Nazi nightie

Everything from SS Christmas cards to Eva Braun's negligée have been put up for grabs in recent years.

This booming sector of the normally sedate collecting world has prompted numerous critics, who see such transactions as at best tasteless.
Hitler greeted by Germans
Hitler is still popular with some collectors
In 1997, a Newcastle auctioneer swore never to deal in Nazi memorabilia again after a storm of local protest halted the sale of a drinking glass given to SS chief Heinrich Himmler by Hitler.

The Canadian War Museum expressed grave concerns about putting a Mercedes limousine owned by the Nazi leader on the market.

Curators feared the exhibit, though sure to raise millions for the museum, might act as a "powerful icon for a neo-Nazi or extreme group".

It's objectionable that people make money from this dubious trade

Searchlight spokesman
The internet auctioneer eBay endured withering criticism from anti-racism organisation the Simon Weisenthal Centre, which charged the company with accepting all manner of Nazi items on its site.

But thousands of lots are regularly auctioned through internet traders. Crockery from the Third Reich, similar to the Nazi memorabilia chillingly featured in the film American Beauty, can be had for around $45.

A spokesman from the anti-fascist magazine Searchlight says the sale of such items is "totally deplorable".
Neo-Nazis in Spain
Today's fascists revel in Nazi regalia
"It's objectionable that people make money from this dubious trade," he says, suggesting that if objects had real historical value they should be offered free to museums.

Private collections of such material are often a symbol of the owner's questionable ideological stance, says the spokesman.

"Some people buy this stuff out of political sympathy for the Nazis. There are a lot of people with SS daggers hanging over the mantelpiece."

Many enthusiasts say they are interested in history, not ideology. Lemmy, lead singer with heavy metal band Motorhead, says his extensive collection celebrates the Nazi taste for "elaborate regalia", not their racist beliefs.

Breaking taboos

American writer Susan Sontag maintains that Nazi memorabilia gives collectors a lurid, taboo-breaking thrill. She likens many of the books on Nazis uniforms and insignia to pornography.

Many auctioneers refuse to be drawn into the debate surrounding the legitimacy of trading in Nazi objects.

Christie's chairman Lord Hindlip has said Nazi memorabilia is "the only thing we categorically will not sell".

His company did however agree to conduct the auction of an Enigma code machine, a piece of Nazi technology which played a decisive role in the outcome of the war.
Italian dictators hat at auction
Mussolini's hat sold for 2,300 in 1998
Richard Westward-Brooks, from the auction house which handled the Hitler "pointer cards" sale, speaking after the sale said historical importance was the benchmark for suitable Nazi lots.

"We don't want to get a reputation as Nazi memorabilia specialists, but if an item is of historical importance we'll treat it in the same way as the Napoleon letters we have sold."

He claimed there was nothing "weird or ghoulish" about things they sell, even the binoculars from Hitler's yacht.

"We're aware of the sensitivities. If somebody brought us Himmler's uniform or something taken from a dead prisoner at Auschwitz we wouldn't touch it," he said.

We didn't have jackboots sounding down the streets of Swindon

Richard Westward-Brooks
The auctioneer rejected demands that the trade in Nazi artefacts should stop, claiming it would skew our understanding of the past.

"You can't ignore history or take a moral standpoint on a particular period," he said, adding that many historically important figures had been morally abhorrent.

Mr Westward-Brooks said the Hitler speech went to a respectable document collector, not a Nazi fanatic.

He said none of those who regularly attend the sales fit the "shaven-headed, tattooed, neo-Nazi" stereotype.

"We didn't have jackboots sounding down the streets of Swindon."

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

21 Jan 00 | UK
Hitler's notes up for sale
28 Oct 98 | Europe
Hitler drawing sold for $10,000
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK stories