[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Tuesday, 3 April 2007, 18:59 GMT 19:59 UK
RAF pilots hear kamikaze scenario
Pilots were asked to consider "life or death" decisions
RAF pilots have been asked to consider the idea of flying suicide missions as a last-ditch tactic against terrorists.

The head of Britain's fast jet squadrons, Air Vice Marshal David Walker, raised the scenario in a "what if" session with senior pilots.

The Ministry of Defence said pilots would never be ordered to sacrifice themselves and the suggestion had only been part of a training exercise.

But the idea was described by Gulf War veteran John Nichol as "abhorrent".

AVM Walker raised the idea while speaking to a group of weapons instructors at RAF High Wycombe in Buckinghamshire from where he commands the air force's 1 Group.

He wanted them to think about how they, and their commanders, would react faced with a life and death decision of the most extreme sort
MoD spokesman

Pilots and commanders had to consider what they would do in a worst case scenario where they had a Taleban or al-Qaeda commander in their sights and found themselves out of ammunition or suffered a weapons failure.

The comments came during a discussion on the changed nature of military operations in the face of attacks like those on 11 September 2001 in the US.

The air vice marshal flew Harrier jump jets with the RAF and was a military assistant to John Reid when he was armed forces minister.

A former RAF navigator John Nichol, whose Tornado jet was shot down during the first Gulf War, said air crews had always been prepared to take enormous risks - even to the point of crashing their planes into the enemy in extreme circumstances.

"Those sort of things have always happened," he said. "But there's a very real difference between somebody saying, 'I'm going to make a personal decision to sacrifice myself', rather than somebody saying, 'I want you to commit suicide'."

Kamikaze is Japanese for "divine wind" - a typhoon that destroyed an invading Mongol fleet
Word used in WWII for Japanese pilots who crashed their planes into allied ships
RAF pilot survived after crashing plane into German bomber heading for Buckingham Palace

Military flyers writing on the Pprune pilots' website have almost universally condemned the idea.

One described the conference discussion as "a true Blackadder moment", referring to the comedy series set in the World War I trenches.

The debate on that website also raised questions over how reliable military intelligence on potential targets might be, with one pilot saying he did not want to die crashing his plane into a Taleban commander only to find he had killed a plumber taking his children to school.

The Ministry of Defence said the suggestion had not been that pilots would be ordered to undertake kamikaze missions.

"He [AVM Walker] wanted them to think about how they, and their commanders, would react faced with a life and death decision of the most extreme sort - for example terrorists trying to fly an aircraft into a British city, being followed by an RAF fighter which suffers weapons failure," said an RAF spokesman

"These are decisions which, however unlikely and dreadful, service people may have to make and it is one of many reasons why the British people hold them in such high esteem."

Are you in the RAF? Are you a pilot? Do you think the training exercise was appropriate? Would you be prepared to undertake suicide missions as a last ditch anti-terror tactic? Send us your comments?

Your E-mail address
Town & Country
Phone number (optional):

The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published. Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide.

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific