[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Sunday, 2 July 2006, 14:04 GMT 15:04 UK
Tory plan to restrict Scots MPs
Former chancellor Kenneth Clarke
Kenneth Clarke wants English MPs voting on English matters
The Conservatives are to recommend Scottish MPs be banned from voting on issues that only affect England.

A party spokesman said the Tories were "almost certain" to back the idea, which has been recommended by a task force led by Kenneth Clarke.

The debate over the post-devolution role for Scottish MPs became known as the "West Lothian question" after being first posed by former MP Tam Dalyell.

Tory leader David Cameron supported the idea in his party's leadership contest.

The measure was also included in the Conservative manifesto at the last election.

Driving further wedges between the nations of the UK cannot be good for our future as a United Kingdom
John, Cambridge

The Tories want to end what they believe is the unfairness of Scottish MPs voting on issues such as health and education in England, although these matters are decided by the Scottish parliament north of the border.

That could dent the leadership credentials of Gordon Brown, who represents a Scottish constituency.

The Conservatives are planning to raise the issue in a debate later this month, but the government is strongly resisting their plans.

Mr Clarke told the Observer newspaper: "If a man landed from Mars and saw the current system, he would not say that democracy was working properly."

Conservative MP Alan Duncan told the BBC it was "absolutely right" to stop MPs voting on issues which did not affect their constituents because they were now decided by the Scottish Parliament.

"I'm beginning to think it is almost impossible now to have a Scottish prime minister because they would be at odds with the basic construction of the British constitution," he said.

"We have MPs from Scotland essentially telling England what to do when they are doing the opposite in Scotland, have no control over what they are doing in their own constituencies in Scotland and are not in any way accountable for the effects their actions have in England."

Two-tier system

Trade and Industry Secretary Alistair Darling spoke out against the Tory plan - saying it would introduce a two-tier system.

"I have always said that there is a huge problem of having two classes of MPs at Westminster," he told the Observer.

"I am a member of this government, I am collectively responsible for everything they do and it would be very odd if you said, well I can't vote for it."

Liberal Democrat Sir Menzies Campbell, MP for North East Fife, warned against any "knee-jerk response" to the issue.

"A constitution is like a brick wall - if you take out one brick without regard to the strength of the wall, it all comes tumbling down.

"What we need is a Constitutional Convention to provide a constitution for 21st Century Britain.

"The Scottish example in advance of home rule shows how it should be done. What we don't need is knee-jerk responses driven by political opportunism."

Why the Tories want the changes to be made

English voters 'oppose Scots PM'
14 May 06 |  Scotland
Scotland set for first Asian MSP
30 Jun 06 |  Glasgow and West
English 'unhappy' with devolution
19 Jun 06 |  Scotland

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific