Thursday, May 20, 1999 Published at 16:21 GMT 17:21 UK
Drugs smugglers' jail terms cut
McLean and Hunter were caught in a customs swoop
Two drug smugglers who were caught in an operation in which a customs officer died have had their jail sentences reduced by seven years.
Roderick McLean senior, 55, who was a key player in the plan to land three tonnes of cannabis worth up to £10m in Scotland, had his prison term reduced from 28 years to 21.
Gary Hunter, 36, a professional diver, also had seven years cut from the 24-year term imposed on him by Lord Dawson.
Mr Soutar (47) from Dundee, was crushed between a customs cutter and the booby-trapped Ocean Jubilee, crewed by McLean and Hunter, which was set alight.
Lord Dawson told the pair and six co-accused when he sentenced them in 1997 at the High Court in Edinburgh that they were involved in a major league smuggling operation.
The judge told McLean he had placed flares and accelerants among the contraband cargo with the intent of destroying it if they were intercepted at sea.
Lord Dawson said: "You put this deadly plan into operation, endangering the lives of a number of officers bravely doing their duty and causing the death of one such officer."
But lawyers argued the pair should not have been sentenced on the basis that they caused Mr Soutar's death. It was also pointed out that the Crown did not charge them with the culpable homicide of the customs officer.
The Lord Justice Clerk, Lord Cullen, who heard the appeal with Lords Kirkwood and Hamilton, said they found the trial judge's reference to the cause of Mr Soutar's death "disturbing".
The senior judge added: "We have come to the conclusion that he misdirected himself in this respect."
A further five years was taken off the sentences imposed on them for the additional charge of attempting to defeat the ends of justice and endangering the lives of customs officers.
Other members of the gang, which included three Dutchmen and an American, still have appeals outstanding.
Mr Soutar's sister, Eleanor Lews, said she was "sickened" by the decision.
She said: "I feel sick, just sick. Hunter was one of the main men involved. They deserved everything they got.
"As far as I'm concerned life sentences for them would have suited me."