Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Archive
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Thursday, March 11, 1999 Published at 15:04 GMT


UK

Mink farm's £5,000 cruelty fine

Video nasty: An animal rights group filmed the evidence

A company that runs a mink farm has been fined £5,000 with £15,000 costs after admitting 15 charges of cruelty and breaches of animal welfare rules.


BBC Correspondent Tim Hirsch reports from New Forest Magistrate's court
The case against the Hampshire farm, where animal rights activists released 6,000 mink last year, is the first of its kind in Britain.

But all the charges against the farmer, Terence Smith, 73, whose farm trades under the name of TT Smith (Mink) Ltd, were dropped.


[ image: Terence Smith: All charges dropped]
Terence Smith: All charges dropped
The evidence was gathered by an animal rights group who made a video of mink at Crowhill Farm near Ringwood. Respect for Animals said after sentencing it was disappointed that the magistrate at Lyndhurst, Hampshire, failed to disqualify the farm from keeping animals.

The RSPCA called for automatic disqualifications in animal cruelty cases.


The BBC's Chris West: The mink were in filthy and dilapidated surroundings
Spokeswoman Lucy Clark said: "We are obviously pleased that this man has been convicted of appalling acts of cruelty to mink but disappointed that he wasn't banned from keeping mink in the future."

Respect for Animals' evidence was passed to the Ministry of Agriculture and the RSPCA who made their own inspections.

They found that some of the mink were suffering some horrendous injuries - some had tails missing, one was found to have died of blood poisoning - yet none of the injured appeared to have been given any veterinary attention.

Maggots and faeces

Oba Nsugbe, prosecuting, said: "Some of the cages had faeces piled up underneath them. Some of the cages were missing nesting boxes and nipple feeders were broken.


Lucy Clark: "We are disappointed"
"Blocked drains were overflowing with maggots and faeces and on that occasion they did see a number of injured mink."

The court heard some of the animals were so badly hurt that bones were protruding from infected wounds, some of which were inflicted by other mink.

Some were in such a bad condition that they had to be put down.

'Chaos' after attack

The company's lawyers explained that there had been attacks on the farm by animal rights activists a few months before the inspection in which several cages were damaged and mink were released.

It was claimed that the chaos caused by that incident led to some of the mink being in such a bad condition.

The mink are normally separated from family groups - making it less likely that the mink would attack each other - but that order had been destroyed.

The UK Government is supporting a Bill currently before Parliament calling for an end to fur farming by 2001.

A Ministry of Agriculture spokesman said: "While fur farming is still going on the Ministry will enforce the highest possible welfare standards.

"We are pleased this prosecution has been successful and will not hesitate to take further action where there is any evidence of cruelty."

  • Respect for Animals claimed another victory over the fur trade on Thursday when the Advertising Standards Authority upheld two complaints against a magazine advert supporting the industry.

    The animal rights group objected to an advert placed in House Magazine, which is circulated widely in Parliament, by the British Fur Trade Association.

    It claimed the advert "blatantly" tried to discredit animal rights groups.

    Complaints were made against four parts of the advert and two were upheld by the ASA.

    However, the ASA dismissed a complaint by the group that fur farming was cruel, stating it was a matter of opinion and not a factual statement.

    A spokeswoman for the British Fur Council accused those campaigning against the fur trade of distorting the facts.

    "People are being misled by animal rights propaganda directed against the fur farming industry," she said.





    Advanced options | Search tips




    Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©


  • UK Contents

    Northern Ireland
    Scotland
    Wales
    England

    Relevant Stories

    05 Mar 99 | UK Politics
    Fur ban bill in Commons

    21 Aug 98 | UK
    'Fearless' mink attack fisherman

    08 Aug 98 | UK
    Mink terrorise Hampshire after farm release





    Internet Links


    RSPCA

    Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food

    International Fur Trade Federation


    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.




    In this section

    Next steps for peace

    Blairs' surprise over baby

    Bowled over by Lord's

    Beef row 'compromise' under fire

    Hamilton 'would sell mother'

    Industry misses new trains target

    From Sport
    Quins fightback shocks Cardiff

    From Business
    Vodafone takeover battle heats up

    IRA ceasefire challenge rejected

    Thousands celebrate Asian culture

    From Sport
    Christie could get two-year ban

    From Entertainment
    Colleagues remember Compo

    Mother pleads for baby's return

    Toys withdrawn in E.coli health scare

    From Health
    Nurses role set to expand

    Israeli PM's plane in accident

    More lottery cash for grassroots

    Pro-lifers plan shock launch

    Double killer gets life

    From Health
    Cold 'cure' comes one step closer

    From UK Politics
    Straw on trial over jury reform

    Tatchell calls for rights probe into Mugabe

    Ex-spy stays out in the cold

    From UK Politics
    Blair warns Livingstone

    From Health
    Smear equipment `misses cancers'

    From Entertainment
    Boyzone star gets in Christmas spirit

    Fake bubbly warning

    Murder jury hears dead girl's diary

    From UK Politics
    Germ warfare fiasco revealed

    Blair babe triggers tabloid frenzy

    Tourists shot by mistake

    A new look for News Online