BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific

BBC News World Edition
 You are in: UK  
News Front Page
Middle East
South Asia
N Ireland
Talking Point
Country Profiles
In Depth
BBC Sport
BBC Weather
Wednesday, 23 October, 2002, 01:33 GMT 02:33 UK
How El Alamein changed the war

Enlarge image
Click here to enlarge the image

Monty became a hero for generations

The battle of El Alamein, 60 years ago on Wednesday, was a key event in British history. For many, it was the moment they believed the war need not be lost.
In Britain in 1942 we needed a boost. We had suffered defeats for the previous two years, and we were demoralised. Morale was at its lowest ebb.

After the Battle of Britain had come the Blitz; I well remember growing up in Brighton. We would shelter from bombs for days or nights on end.

Battle of El Alamein
  • Date: 23 October 1942
  • Strategic importance: On the Egyptian coast, El Alamein was seen as a gateway to the Suez & N Africa
  • In command: General Montgomery (above, left) for Allies, General Rommel (right) for Axis powers
  • Allied victory: After El Alamein, Allies gained upper-hand in N Africa & swept through to Tripoli
  • Turning point: As Churchill reflected: "Before Alamein, we never had a victory - after Alamein we never had a defeat"
  • I remember being hurried by our mother to shelter in the basement, and with the wailing of the sirens, waiting for our father who had lost a leg and part of an arm at Mons in World War I; he took minutes longer than us to get to the shelter.

    The British seemed to keep losing battles; we were always on the defensive.

    Needing a victory

    Germany had invaded Greece and Yugoslavia. Hong Kong had surrendered to the Japanese, who also captured Singapore. Our battleships the Prince of Wales and Repulse had been sunk. U-boats started sinking ships in the Atlantic which were bringing us food and arms.

    And bombing at home was continuing - more than 1,000 bombers attacked Canterbury in June 1942. Thousands of Canadians were killed in the raid on Dieppe.

    Enlarge image
    Enlarge image

    The strength of the Allies took the Germans by surprise
    Somehow we needed a victory.

    The longed-for breakthrough came after the start of the Battle of El Alamein on 23 October 1942.

    El Alamein is in Egypt, about 50 miles from Alexandria and on the east of the Mediterranean. It's a good place to have a swim and get refreshed from the sand and dust you had collected on whatever journey you were on. Most important, as El Alamein is by the sea, ships can unload and cargo can then go on to the trains.

    At that time in North Africa, the Eighth Army - "The Desert Rats" - seemed to be holding ground against the Germans. There were many casualties from skirmishes, but it looked like the allies were in good force.

    However in January 1942, the Germans under Rommel opened a second offensive, and the Allied losses started again. When Tobruk fell, 30,000 men were captured, many of them South Africans.
    Enlarge image
    Enlarge image

    Monty's plan was the reverse of Rommel's
    Rommel's plan was to attack El Alamein to the east and, going through Egypt, eventually take Cairo.

    Montgomery had the reverse plan and wanted somehow to get through the mine fields and attack through the German lines - going west and, hopefully, carrying on through Libya and Tunisia and onwards, eventually leaving the Afrika Korps out of North Africa.

    At home, first reports in the papers and on the radio were conservative about what was happening. On 24 October, the Times said: "The latest information from the western desert, is that apart from patrol activities, there is nothing to report."

    However, the next day, it said that "at night the guns have made a barrage like an earthquake". The correspondent wrote: "A man told me that the Germans and Italians alike were badly shaken by the heavy barrage which the Eighth Army attack opened."

    On the 27th, the paper said: "Eighth Army holding on to new positions - 1450 Axis prisoners taken." The next day said: "Allied progress in desert battle," and on the 29th it said "Axis forces hurled back!" They also said the RAF had had victories in the air and was now getting on top in the air battle.


    Eventually, from this victory at El Alamein, in three months we had swept from the east to where they met a British and American fleet at Tripoli. In history, Winston Churchill would write in The Hinge of Fate his famous verdict: "Before Alamein we never had a victory. After Alamein, we never had a defeat."

    At that time, at home, everyone was of course delighted by the news. In the UK, many church bells rang for the first time since the beginning of war - they were usually silenced, only to be rung if the Germans had invaded. The pubs were now full - people now savouring the taste of victory. Although it was early days, everyone needed to know that this might be the turn of the tide in the war.

    At last it was time to enjoy these special victory days and at home we had a big party, as did people in thousands of homes throughout the country. We children were allowed to stay up, while our home was filled with relatives, friends and people we had only known recently.

    I would remember this party, two-and-a-half years later, when we celebrated again

    One of the friends at that party was BBC newsreader Bruce Belfrage who, with his family, lived in a flat in our house in Brighton. Having him there talking about the western war and El Alamein gave the house the most atmospheric feeling.

    I would remember this party, two-and-a-half years later, when we celebrated again. That time the celebrations were for victory in Europe on VE Day.

    But at the time, I listened to the loud talking and happy laughter of celebrating adults, as their drinks flowed too generously. Everyone we met, whether we knew them or not, seemed to be part of a huge family party, which in way we were.

    David Knowles is author of With Resolve - With Valour, and Escape from Catastrophe - 1940 Dunkirk.

    Internet links:

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

    Links to more UK stories are at the foot of the page.

     E-mail this story to a friend

    Links to more UK stories

    © BBC ^^ Back to top

    News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East |
    South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature |
    Technology | Health | Talking Point | Country Profiles | In Depth |